Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Returns - What is Right & Wrong?

who's talking here?

Banannie 3
Wish you were me 1
notmuchlonger 1
Jamie (Sake's momma) 11
boone 1
Livinlife 12
MissyLouWho 2
Scrappy 8
Girlie Girl 1
Peone 1
Sam 4
Kye77 27
Paul 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

So I bought an item off this lady & purposely went to meet her 40 minutes from my home to collect it. When I got home & tried it(I shant say what it is because then she'll know & if she reads this, RUCKUS!), it did not work. FAULTY! I emailed her the same day & she replied the next day. She said that it worked for her, she has a busy schedule & if I wanted to return it, I'd have to go to her home to do so after a certain time which I couldn't do. Since weekdays seem impossible, I offered to make the 40 minute trip on a weekend again. I say again because I went to meet her on a weekend too. Now she says, she has NO idea when she will be home because she tends to be out all weekend. So what was last weekend all about? My question is: Is this right? A buyer made an effort to buy your item. It has inconvenienced the buyer. Isn't an apology due? Shouldn't you make sure you take the item back & give her a refund ASAP & not go on with your life like usual? I do not believe I've been unreasonable as I've been trying to accommodate & find a good day/time for the both of us but she isn't trying. What should be the morally right procedure for returning a faulty item? 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

Sadly PYS isnt like a store. When you buy an item you should try it before you leave the sellers home to see if it works. Once you buy it its yours. Not saying you would do this but there are some that will buy things, accidently break it and then say they were sold an item that didnt work. Its the chance you take with yard sale items. 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

I meant OYS not PYS 

Sam --- 17 years ago -

I've sold something that didn't work. I asked my husband if it worked, he said it did, so I never bothered to check (you know how husbands go...he thought I was talking about "something else"). Anyway, I mailed her a check for the item. It happens sometimes. If you sell something that's broken, you are a piece of crap for not refunding the money. As a buyer, you should check just in case and avoid buying electronics, etc. my 2 cents ;) 

Sam --- 17 years ago -

I've sold something that didn't work. I asked my husband if it worked, he said it did, so I never bothered to check (you know how husbands go...he thought I was talking about "something else"). Anyway, I mailed her a check for the item. It happens sometimes. If you sell something that's broken, you are a piece of crap for not refunding the money. As a buyer, you should check just in case and avoid buying electronics, etc. my 2 cents ;) 

Paul --- 17 years ago -

sorry IMO WYSIWYG-what you see is what you get, buyer beware! It sucks, but there are dishonest people everywhere. 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

Gee, I know it isn't a store. However, there are just many things that cannot be tried when you meet up for collection. She did say that it would work for sure. After your input, I'm starting to have very little faith in buying electronics or anything I'd have to test from sellers on OYS, especially if they only do meet up. 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

I agree it does suck, Thats why I dont buy that kind of stuff on here. I check everything before I sell it. Esp games and movies. 

Paul --- 17 years ago -

I'm starting to have very little faith in buying electronics or anything I'd have to test from sellers on OYS, especially if they only do meet up. That is a good point, if someone is not willing to allow you to pick up an item at their home, red flags should probably go off. 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

Well, she IS saying I can return it. However, she is being dismissive about it. That is the hard part. I will have to really go out of my way to return this one. It sucks but I'd rather do that than be stuck with something I cannot use. 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

I dont understand why you have to go to her to get a refund. If it doesnt work why does she want it back? Why cant she MPS you the refund? For that matter you could MPS the item back too if she wants to check it out. 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

That is a good point, if someone is not willing to allow you to pick up an item at their home, red flags should probably go off. In this case, I suggested the landmark on the base she lived on. However, she has told me to go to her home to return it. She told me her building number & I am to call her so she can come out to meet me. 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

I dont understand why you have to go to her to get a refund. If it doesnt work why does she want it back? Why cant she MPS you the refund? For that matter you could MPS the item back too if she wants to check it out. Did you know that using MPS is not allowed? I suppose shipping the refund is fine. See under Prohibited Shipping items sold on the site via Military Postal Service is prohibited (see DoD 4525.6M (Postal Manual)) 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

Isnt allowed for what? Its free to ship stuff from base to base here which is what the post office told me. Why would it be illegal if its free and allowed? Im confused. 

Paul --- 17 years ago -

Isnt allowed for what? Its free to ship stuff from base to base here which is what the post office told me. Why would it be illegal if its free and allowed? Im confused. I think she might be referring to the "use of military postal system for running a business"...in that sense it could be viewed as illegal. So could all of the candles, pampered chef, and everything else that people do. 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

See this on the OYS site http://www.okinawayardsales.com/prohibited.jsp 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

I think she might be referring to the "use of military postal system for running a business"...in that sense it could be viewed as illegal. So could all of the candles, pampered chef, and everything else that people do. Gosh, now I'm confused. So am I or am I not allowed to do so? 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

I think she might be referring to the "use of military postal system for running a business"...in that sense it could be viewed as illegal. So could all of the candles, pampered chef, and everything else that people do. Aint that the truth lol. People use it for all kinds of things all the time. I was giving her a suggestion to keep from driving 45 mins but hey whatever floats the boat : ) 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

It also says this under prohib listings: Counterfeit goods (including purse and watch replicas). These are illegal and authorities will prosecute. However every day I seem KO coach stuff and they keep letting people post it 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

Blimey! She said it worked for her but it was supposed to be new OUT of box. The sticker underneath has some of its words rubbed off. I should have checked! I'm just so dumb :( 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

It also says this under prohib listings: Counterfeit goods (including purse and watch replicas). These are illegal and authorities will prosecute. However every day I seem KO coach stuff and they keep letting people post it On that note, hmmm, this could be a good idea! I wonder if she'd be open to it.. Maybe she'll have some excuse about being unable to go to the post office? OR she will claim she sent the refund but never did? GAH, I'm now so suspicious of everything! The good thing is... it aint all that expensive. I just feel it's the moral of the whole issue. 

Sam --- 17 years ago -

That is a good point, if someone is not willing to allow you to pick up an item at their home, red flags should probably go off. I never let people come to my home to pick anything up, and I never will. 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

I never let people come to my home to pick anything up, and I never will. Now, that's curious. What about big big items huh? You would meet up or you never sell big big items? 

Paul --- 17 years ago -

I never let people come to my home to pick anything up, and I never will. Then unless I am buying a book or something simple from you I probably wouldn't buy it. 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

Then unless I am buying a book or something simple from you I probably wouldn't buy it. I should be more like you! :( 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I'm starting to have very little faith in buying electronics Test it out before you buy.. if you meet at BK parking lot, go inside and plug it in. Or let the seller know you want to try it out first, so picking it up at your home or somewhere where there is a plugin is a must :) Kye- I would suggest it to her.. I think using the MPS for a refund is completey okay. I don't see how you could get into any trouble for that :) 

Paul --- 17 years ago -

I didn't mean to sound harsh, but when buying things online, classifieds, flea market or whatever, you have to be a little cautious. I won't buy electronics at a flea market. If I can't test it, I don't buy it. Here in Okinawa, people sell movies and video games all the time that are region coded, but don't tell the buyers. So you have to be careful. 

Peone --- 17 years ago -

Here in Okinawa, people sell movies and video games all the time that are region coded, but don't tell the buyers. So you have to be careful. What do you mean by region coded? 

notmuchlonger --- 17 years ago -

So here is my 2 cents worth...first off I don't like people comming to my home because YOU may be nice but the next guy may not be. Who knows who is out there now a days. I think the reason she may be willing to let you come to her building now is because she has met you and knows your not some creep! And I am sure if you let her know if you will be on her base even a few days from now she will be willing to try to met with you. Maybe the last few days have been exceptionally busy for her. We should all know being military spouses our lives are never empty! Stick it out and hopefully you will get your money soon!! 

Kye77 --- 17 years ago -

Nah, I don't think she is being evasive about her home & all since she gave me her building number. She actually read this post & she email to assure me that I will get my refund & I believe her. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground