Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What's our opinion?

who's talking here?

Kitty 4
peachyme 1
Jamie (Sake's momma) 43
Ennui 12
nikita08 1
Texas girl 5
┌∩┐(◕_ 4
Krystle 10
southern gal 38
Bryn 1
Nicole 19
lilloudymouth 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

If your child was diagnosed with cancer would you disregard proven treatments to save their life or would you disregard them? Here are the numbers for those who do not want to read the article below: 5% chance of life without treatment 90% chance of life with treatment Basically in a nutshell a 13 year old has a type of cancer that can be treated and allow him to live his life with the use of chemo. He went through one treatment which naturally like chemo does made him sick and he didn't like feeling that way so when round two came up and the boy didn't want the treatment they were court ordered to continue on with their sessions. The mother and son then fled the state to avoid the treatment and want to find "a natural way" to cure this cancer rather then something that is "toxic" to him. I am wondering where you would stand in this situation. I have a family with a few cancer survivors in it all of which went under chemo and I understand the effects that it can have on a person that are unfavorable, although, they are all living happy healthy cancer free lives now after being strong and pushing through the hard times. I can not imagine looking a chance at life right in the face and letting it down just because they didn't like feeling sick after treatment, and as a parent I would do my best to encourage my child to be strong and do everything I can to make them understand that this is going to be the best thing for them. Just wondering how others feel. : -) The article: NEW ULM, Minn. - A 13-year-old cancer patient and his mother, who fled Minnesota last week to avoid court-ordered chemotherapy for him, returned voluntarily Monday, and the boy was examined by a doctor. Daniel Hauser was "immediately checked over medically" when he and his mother arrived on a charter flight at 3 a.m., Brown County Sheriff Rich Hoffmann said. On a video released by the sheriff's department, Colleen Hauser described how the first chemotherapy treatment Daniel received made him sick and she said he planned to run away from home. "Then what do I have? I mean, he was going to run," Hauser said. "And that just broke my heart. I can't have one of my children running away from something that they should face." Hauser expresses optimism that her son can beat cancer, but the video doesn't disclose where they were or when it was made. The video was produced by Asgaard Media, which also arranged the charter flight for the mother and son to return home. At one point on the video, an unseen woman asks Daniel what he'd say to people who claim he's not old enough to decide whether he needs chemotherapy. "I'd tell them to back off," he replies. Hoffmann said Jennifer Keller, an attorney from Orange County, Calif., contacted the sheriff's office and the FBI Sunday to say Colleen Hauser wanted to bring her son home. Keller said she met the mother and son on Sunday, then notified authorities and arranged the private jet. Keller said the public outcry is misguided and criticism pointed at Colleen Hauser is unfair. "They always expected to return," Keller told The Associated Press in a phone interview late Monday. "She's horrified people perceive her as hiding out. That isn't what she intended." Keller said Daniel Hauser looked fine but was tired. "He was very, very eager to get home," she said. Keller said Colleen Hauser would continue to explore treatments "that aren't toxic" to Daniel. However, she said Hauser plans to abide by what the court says. Brown County Attorney James Olson said he likely would dismiss the felony complaint against Colleen Hauser because she returned voluntarily. Minneapolis FBI spokesman E.K. Wilson said the federal charge of unauthorized flight also likely would be dropped. Hodgkin's lymphoma has a 90 percent cure rate in children if treated with chemotherapy and radiation, but doctors say Daniel has a 5 percent chance of survival without those treatments. He underwent one round of chemotherapy in February, but none since. The family cited religious beliefs in opting for natural healing practices inspired by American Indians. A judge ruled that the parents medically neglected Daniel and ordered them to get him an updated chest X-ray as well as select an oncologist for a re-evaluation. After the X-ray showed a tumor in Daniel's chest has grown, the mother and son left town. On Thursday, Anthony Hauser appeared before reporters asking his wife to come home "so we can decide as a family what Danny's treatment should be." The sheriff didn't say whether Daniel received medical treatment for his Hodgkin's lymphoma while they were gone. "It is a good day as Daniel and Colleen Hauser have been safely returned to Minnesota," Hoffmann said. Daniel Hauser was evaluated at a hospital in the Twin Cities on Monday and his parents were with him, according to Tom Hagen, an attorney at the law office representing the parents. Daniel was expected to spend Monday night at his family's farm in Sleepy Eye, about 100 miles southwest of the Twin Cities. A court order placed Daniel in protective custody last week, but Olson said family services was comfortable allowing Daniel to stay with his parents. A deputy was posted at the farm Monday night, Olson added. Dr. Bruce Bostrom, the pediatric oncologist at Children's Hospitals and Clinics of Minnesota who diagnosed Daniel's cancer in January, said he was happy to hear of the boy's return. "I'm delighted," Bostrom said. "I've been so worried that he was going to die in Mexico. I've been praying for his safe return, so I think my prayers will be answered." Bostrom was not working Monday and didn't know if Daniel had gone to Children's Hospitals to be examined. The voice message system at Asgaard Media of Corona, Calif., was full and a message could not be left. The film and television production company did not immediately return an e-mail request for comment.  

peachyme --- 17 years ago -

I think it depends on the situation. I've had lots of family members/friends die from cancer. Even with chemo. They were all older and didn't take care of themselves though. If it was my kid I'd probably make them do the treatments but I don't know what I'd do if my kid said it hurt him/her and they didn't want to do it anymore. Its a sad situation. 

nikita08 --- 17 years ago -

Honestly... I would try everything possible to save my childs life... I wouldn't deny the treatments especially with success numbers like that... I just wouldn't be able to live with myself knowing I didn't try. 

┌∩┐(◕_ --- 17 years ago -

Once again, this is the problem with today's society. People cant freakin tell their kids NO. Obviously, he has a better chance of survival WITH Chemo, so he just needs to deal with the side effects if he wants a chance to live. 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

Once again, this is the problem with today's society. People cant freakin tell their kids NO. You hit the nail on the head!!! The kid shouldn't be the one making the decision here. He's a KID. He doesn't have enough life experience to make a decision like this. And WHY IN THE WORLD would parents stand by and let their child CHOOSE to die??? It's just crazy all the way around. I think that mom should be charged with neglect. 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

I don't know what I'd do if my kid said it hurt him/her and they didn't want to do it anymore I think the thing is no kid is going to enjoy the chemo. Yes it is going to make you sick and you are not going to like it but it's going give you a much better shot at living. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I would encourage the child to do treatment.. but I think (since he is not 4) if he didnt want to- then it is his choice.. he would have to go through it.. yknow? 

┌∩┐(◕_ --- 17 years ago -

I didn't see anything to do with religion in it 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

I agree, I think it was religion drivin. I don't get it though...what is it about their religion that says the kid should die instead of getting proper treatment???? Jamie...I have to disagree. It doesn't matter that he's a teenager. He's still NOT an adult. A parent's job is to make the hard choices for their children. A kid isn't in the position to make a hard choice like whether to feel bad for a little while and LIVE -or- to feel good right now and DIE later. Those are choices he CAN'T understand at 13 years old. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

Jamie...I have to disagree. It doesn't matter that he's a teenager. He's still NOT an adult. A parent's job is to make the hard choices for their children. A kid isn't in the position to make a hard choice like whether to feel bad for a little while and LIVE -or- to feel good right now and DIE later. Those are choices he CAN'T understand at 13 years old. That is your opinion- mine differs. My brother and sister we able to choose if they wanted to live with their mother or father at age 13. (i know not exactly the same thing) but their mom was/is really bad news.. and the judge let them make that choice. A parent's job is to make the hard choices for their children. Okay, well then the mother had made her hard choice ( i know they are back home now) and she got ridiculed for it.. so saying it is the parents choice is not a good argument to me. 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

Good counter points... I do think that giving a child a choice to live with one parent or another is quite different from giving a child a choice as to whether he wants to live or die though. In both situations, the child would have to deal with consequences. But in the situation with cancer, the consequence is DYING. And you're right, the mom did make a hard choice. But what I really meant was that parents have to make hard choices that are responsible. I didn't clarify. I think a parent has to be the one to say, "NO, we are sticking through this chemo. It's gonna suck for a while. But in the end, it'll be worth it." To me that's the equivalent of making a hard choice that a kid can't understand. Ok, counter me...this is fun. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

But what I really meant was that parents have to make hard choices that are responsible. But if it is the parents choice to make- then it is their choice... to me- they aren't abusing him.. i think the courts should ask the boy what he wants (inform him of what comes along with each option) and let him decide. I don't think they should be TOLD he HAS to do it.. that is alot for anyone to go through- some people would rather live out their lives without the chemo and die peacefully.. we all die anyways- at least he would get a say in how. I know that the living with mom and cancer are completely different.. but it is the kids life- they have to live (or die) with that choice.. if they want to die- so be it. if he didnt want to go through chemo bad enough- whose to say he wont just commit suicide? 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

True, he could still commit suicide if he didn't want to go through it all. In that case it wouldn't be much different than him fore-going the chemo. I just have a hard time believing that a 13 year old can truly understand that choice. In general, kids are focused on the here and now...not down the road. So, of course a kid would say, "I don't want to feel yucky for a few months." Who does? But if it means he can live 80 years instead of 15...isn't that little bit of time spent puking worth it??? Yes, true...we all do live and die. But he has a 90% survival rate with chemo. I am not good at laying down and giving up. But it isn't MY choice. But really, WHY should he just give up when he can beat this??? I've seen people with practically NO survival rate fight harder...and still make it through. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

.isn't that little bit of time spent puking worth it??? Maybe- but I don't think the government should be able to make that choice for the family unless the kid is saying I WANT CHEMO and mom is saying no. But really, WHY should he just give up when he can beat this??? I've seen people with practically NO survival rate fight harder...and still make it through. Sometimes people just give up. I would imagine all that really drains a person- maybe they just want it all to be over with- and to leave the world on their own terms (meaning by choice) and leave it at that. I could see both sides. Yes- chemo has a 90% chance- but it is a long hard fight- it may just be better for him to die - if that is what he wants.. either way it is a scary situation- and like i said- i dont think it is right for the government to tell you what you have to do in this case. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I just have a hard time believing that a 13 year old can truly understand that choice. And whose to say a 18 year old or 50 year old would make a better choice? As long as someone explains what will happen with both options- then he should be able to make an educated decision (with his parents help) IMO now I think if he says no and parents say yes- it should be his choice- or visa versa 

Bryn --- 17 years ago -

I thought the kid had a learning disability of some sort? I remember reading that in an article. 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

It's a double edged sword. I don't really want the government all in my business either. But, I don't think parents should be allowed to just let their kid die when there is a possibility for him to overcome this. Life isn't easy. Period. Unfortunately for some people that "isn't easy" part comes with chemo. I don't have a really good valid arguement for that...just an opinion. However, to through this into a similar yet different discussion...I do think the mom should be charged with neglect. I think she is being negligent in her care of her minor child. That goes back to the point that I don't think kids CAN make a decision like this, and that a parent has to make the hard decisions (i.e. It isn't fun to puke for a few months, but we'll stick it out to get you well). 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I thought the kid had a learning disability of some sort? I remember reading that in an article. Im not sure- if he does- then depending on what all is affected by it.. maybe his making the choice would not be a good idea. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I don't really see neglect (but i havent read the whole story) maybe kidnapping... 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

I thought the kid had a learning disability of some sort? I remember reading that in an article. I'm pretty sure he's unable to read due to a learning disability. I would do chemo for my child. I also agree at 13 they really aren't prepared to make a decision like this. The only way I think they are is if they have been chronically ill since a very young age and in constant pain and poor quality of life. As for me, I could not live with myself if I did nothing and just allowed my child to die. You do everything you can, until the downside of the treatment far outweights the benefit. 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

I just have a hard time believing that a 13 year old can truly understand that choice. And whose to say a 18 year old or 50 year old would make a better choice? Well the truth is that an 18 year old or a 50 year old might just make that decision...but they are ADULTS. The law says that as an ADULT you can make those decisions for yourself. However, the 13 year old is NOT an adult by legal standards. And to take this a step further...if a 13 year old is capable of determining if he/she wants to live or die...then shouldn't a 13 year old also be able to stand trial as an adult when they shoot someone or steal something...if we are going to let them make adult decisions, we let them have adult consequences (such as dying when you choose not to go through chemo). 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

then shouldn't a 13 year old also be able to stand trial as an adult when they shoot someone or steal something... And some do. 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

But most don't. Most are sent to juvy b/c our system doesn't think they should be sent to jail with the adults. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

Well like I said- we have different opinions- I think the parents should make the choice- and if the kid doesnt agree- they should be able to go to the courts and try to fight it 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

Yep, that's the great thing about being Americans...we CAN have our different opinions. It was fun to have a good discussion though. We haven't had as many of those on here lately! 

┌∩┐(◕_ --- 17 years ago -

Where are you guys getting that it was a religious decision? The article says that the boy went in for one chemo treatment and didn't want to go back because of how it made him feel. He also said he would tell people to "back off" if they said he needed the treatment. It was nothing religious at all. 

┌∩┐(◕_ --- 17 years ago -

ok wayyy late response, lol. thats what i get for being busy at work :-p 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

lol 

southern gal --- 17 years ago -

The family cited religious beliefs in opting for natural healing practices inspired by American Indians. Mika...that's a quote from the article. I don't REALLY think they were being "religious" with their decision. I think they knew that was the only reason that our government will take for opting to not allow a minor to have medical treatment...and even then, the government can overrule the parents. 

lilloudymouth --- 17 years ago -

I dont care what the reason the mother is giving, it makes no sense to say "my child wants to die so Im going to let him choose that" It was said hes got a great chance to live with treatment. There would be no question...He would get the treatment 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground