Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

What is your opinion?

who's talking here?

Paul 6
Loved living in Oki 3
Nicole 4
Misses Eriksson 1
♥Mrs. Boss ♥ 1
yourmomdotcom 1
Blue fuzzy creature 8
Illbehave 10
SFC :) 1
JennaDoll 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

JennaDoll --- 16 years ago -

There are two guys in my husbands unit that have both failed 4 PT tests.

Story 1:
TSgt failed his 4th about 5 weeks ago, after the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd fail, he was put into the FB program and then failed his 4th. He's still sitting pretty.

Story 2:
SrA failed his 4th last week, and he's already had a meeting with the commander to decide if they're going to discharge him or let him have one more chance.

Obviously, TSgt is older, however, he's not a "nonner" and doesn't sit at a desk all day, he's much "larger" than SrA. SrA has been stationed here about one year longer than the TSgt.

How is this fair? I agree that they should BOTH pass their PT tests, it's part of the military requirement, but why is the "younger" guy being punished and they have yet to say a word to the TSgt? Is there something I'm missing? TSgt is still several years away from retirement, so I know that's not what they are waiting for. 

Paul --- 16 years ago -

Two chances. Fail both and get processed out. Don't care who you are. The only reason anyone should get further consideration is mitigating circumstances (previous documented surgery/injury). 

JennaDoll --- 16 years ago -

You know, I know both of these guys, and am quite friendly with both (house parties/holidays/etc) They're both single, one lives in the dorms, one lives out in town. Therefore, one is cooking for himself or eating out, so you KNOW he has "better" options to eat healthy. The other one is a dorm-dweller, so he's on a meal card, that means a set menu from what the chow hall has. I just think it sucks that he's not getting a chance, but the TSgt is in the clear. He didn't even get pulled for a discussion.

I just keep telling my husband, yeah, going to the gym sucks, not eating that second cheeseburger sucks, but do you want to be in his position? It's crappy, but you gotta do what you gotta do. 

JennaDoll --- 16 years ago -

I know how you feel. I work with a TSgt that hasn't passed one in 4 years. I had to deploy last minute because of him yet he's still collecting a paycheck every two weeks.


If I'm not mistaken, isn't it, you have 2 per year now? And, I thought after your 3rd, you get pulled to discuss. My husband is AF, so I don't know if this holds true for all branches. How in the hell is he still in??!!?? 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

I think you should automatically be processed out after your 2nd failure.

People know the rules and circumstances, you passed the test to join, no need to get fat and lazy once your comfortable.... 

SFC :) --- 16 years ago -

Two chances. Fail both and get processed out. Don't care who you are. The only reason anyone should get further consideration is mitigating circumstances (previous documented surgery/injury).


I agree with Paul. It is unacceptable unless there is an injury or medical condition documented. 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

If that's the case, then a MEB needs to be done to process them for medical discharge. 


It depends. I'd say if they were hurt in combat they should be cut some slack. 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

What about someone who is over their max weight but gets a 1st class PFT? 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

Isn't there a "max weight" for a reason? If you know what your max is there is no reason to go over it, 1st class PFT or not. 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

I think fat spouses should be dealt with too. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

Max weight for spouses is really on a marriage by marriage basis. 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

If all the weight goes to the a s s and boobs it's all good. 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

Max spouse weight = service members weight+20% 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

Max spouse weight = service members wight+20% 

That would make me huge. 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

That would make me huge.

For the most part it would keep everyone under about 300lbs I would think.

There are plenty of biggums waddling around base heavier than that.... 

Paul --- 16 years ago -

Max spouse weight = service members wight+20%


I didn't know there would be Algebra today! 

Paul --- 16 years ago -

wrong thread 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

Problem is people may start failing twice on purpose just to get out. 

JennaDoll --- 16 years ago -

I agree they should have to pass, but what I'm wondering is, do you think it's unfair the SrA is getting punished and not the TSgt?? 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

Problem is people may start failing twice on purpose just to get out.

This might not be a bad thing. As long as they keep the discharge to anything other than honorable.

Would you really want to be working with the kind of people who would rather get out in this manner? 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

unfair the SrA is getting punished and not the TSgt??

It's the way the military rolls. People with more time and rank usually slide by a little easier than those w/out.... 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

I say the TSgt should be punished worse. He is a SNCO and should be setting the example.

Tge SrA I blame his NCOs as well as him as if they were doing their job he would probably pass. 

Paul --- 16 years ago -

I think the TSgt should be forced to give his wife 1/2 of his retirement! :o 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

Hahahaha. Nice. 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

I think the TSgt should be forced to give his wife 1/2 of his retirement! :o

FTW! 

Misses Eriksson --- 16 years ago -

Who cares. 

♥Mrs. Boss ♥ --- 16 years ago -

Are you positive that this Tsgt has not had any reprimand and you are just not aware of it? I mean he is a Tsgt, I can't see him getting into trouble and making it publicly known to everyone that he got paperwork.

I thought the new AF standards for the PT test was if you fail 2 times you get paperwork out? If not that is how it should be. LOL.

Also if SRA gets paperwork or a ticket out, you have to look at it this way also...they are going to get rid of the person whom they have spent less money on already. The Tsgt has had a lot more money invested in him for training ect.

And for the record, No I do not think it is fair if this higher ranking person has not received any reprimand. No matter what your rank, if you can't follow the standards and pass your PT test you should get in trouble (unless their is medical reasoning why). 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

I say the TSgt should be punished worse. He is a SNCO and should be setting the example.

This is the Air Force, not the Marine Corp. A TSgt isn't a SNCO. 



I mean NCO. In any case he should be dealt with more severely than a SrA IMHO. 

JennaDoll --- 16 years ago -

Are you positive that this Tsgt has not had any reprimand and you are just not aware of it? I mean he is a Tsgt, I can't see him getting into trouble and making it publicly known to everyone that he got paperwork.


Yes, he's my husband's "supervisor". 

JennaDoll --- 16 years ago -

Tge SrA I blame his NCOs as well as him as if they were doing their job he would probably pass.


You can't force someone to not be lazy. You can't force him to eat a salad, go to the gym, etc. There is only so much one can do before it starts showing on EPR's and such, so I don't think this is a fair statement either. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground