Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Is it wrong to ask for help? (e3 discussion/free items)

who's talking here?

Just another girl 1
Banannie 1
Wish you were me 1
Kitty 3
MOMZ 1
chica 3
Mr. Party Wagon 2
Jamie (Sake's momma) 5
AznNvazn912 1
Rescue101 2
April 1
lilmama 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Is it wrong to ask for help? (e3 discussion/free items)

Let's keep it off OYS.

YES Vote
 
 15.8% (3)
NO Vote
 
 84.2% (16)
Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

Let's keep it off OYS. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

This is my take on it: we dont know the other peoples circumstances. I am not one to judge. If they are asking for help, why put them down? If you needed help and asked for it, Im sure someone would help you. We are a military family like it or not, we don't know if they got raped, their baby daddy died, or ANY circumstances other than they say they need help and that they are an E3 and single. Just because they are military does not mean the baby daddy is. If you don't want to help, DON'T. It is as simple as that. I hope you guys aren't proud of the posts that say that person if selfish. I think it is PATHETIC that people responded that way, I know there are heartless people in the world, but we are military families.. we are supposed to be their for each other. and even if precautions were taken, accidents happen. condoms break, you can get prego while on birth control. Anyways, my point is, they are not asking for your opinion, they asked for your help.. if you are not willing to help then their post was not directed towards you, so why bother clicking it!? I am sure there is SOMEONE who has something to help this woman with.. Why take that away from someone?? BTW- My dad died when I was 1. So THINGS HAPPEN! Anyways, I am glad she kept the baby and did not opt for an abortion, but that is a whole other she-bang. All I know is she is asking for help. That is like yelling at an alcoholic for going to a counselor.. He drank.. but he still needs help. Regaurdless of that fact that we all know sex makes babies, she has a baby coming.. so if people don't think it is right for her to prepare for HER CHILD by whatever (legal) means necessary. I DO DISAGREE with beggars being choosers. as zx9rgirl and I discussed in another thread :) 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

Not wrong to ask for help by any means* *However asking for help is much different from begging for things as was mentioned above and in a number of different places and so on. . . If you need something THAT bad it doesn't matter what condition it is in (obviously not crazy torn or w/e but I am sure most know what I mean by this) I also don't think that it is wrong for someone who is willing to help to ask about the situation further of the person who needs the help. It doesn't need to be public but asking about things to learn a bit more about that person maybe to understand better if they actually NEED the help or just don't want to work for what they need. (I.E. they have things that they don't want to get rid of like an xbox but don't have the money for baby clothes) And yes if you are asking for my help and you REALLY need it you should be able to share more information then your rank. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I agree :) 

Rescue101 --- 17 years ago -

Ok. My husband is an E-3. It's the only income we have. We are NOT the type of people who go out all the time, buy all kinds of stuff... not in the slightest. In fact we ONLY buy what we need, and no more... we do not go out to eat, we don't go to the movies... we pay our bills, buy groceries and gas... and when that is all done... we don't have much of anything left. We're having our first child in April, and we bought most everything we needed, but there were still things left to get and no more money left to spend... People were VERY kind and helped me out. I couldn't be more thankful. It's hard to make it on what you have sometimes... there is NOTHING wrong with asking for help... everyone needs a little bit of help now and then. We're all in the military, we've all been there at one point. Some enter the military with previous debts, some enter with a clean slate... either way everyone has a different story, and everyone has a different budget. We are supposed to all get along, and HELP each other... not harass one another. If you don't want to help... don't. SIMPLE as that. No need to be judge mental. For those of you who are... the day will come when you're going to need a little help and guess what... you're not going to get it. At least I hope you don't. GROW UP. You're not 14... Stop acting like it. Please. 

chica --- 17 years ago -

I have to say.....do not judge someone unless you want to be judged. I have no idea what is going on in her life so I am certainly not going to judge her.....I do know this the DRAMA on OYS lately is making this not a fun place anymore...I have sold lots of things and I have gotten some great deals on things I was looking for.....but lately I can not stand the drama anymore....but hey I guess when you have been to the war zone and back like myself you just do not have the patience for childish behavior anymore!!! It is a shame that this has to happen on here because this was a great place to do business before and make a few extra dollars! Definitely makes me think about how people act!! 

Rescue101 --- 17 years ago -

Absolutely... 

chica --- 17 years ago -

Random...I totally agree with you their day will come...I see lots of hard times but i have always managed to get throught them with the help of family and friends....and thank god for them....I can not believe how these people are acting on here....it is crazy....but you know what I believe in KARMA and it is B#@ch 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

It's honestly pathetic in a word. I don't believe that everyone HAS to get along and I don't think that everyone HAS to agree that is part of being a human but to sit there and say some of the things that have been said in a place where it is not meant to be said then that is wrong. If it is going to make feathers fly put it here not on a place where people are trying to sell their goods. 

chica --- 17 years ago -

 

Mr. Party Wagon --- 17 years ago -

i think there are other ways to get help, but don't think this was wrong by any means. for example, Uncle Sam's Attic on Kadena is a great place to get all sorts of household items for free (they give you a monthly allowance of free stuff!!). some people don't know about these places that can help them. for example, the lady who needed cheap luggage about a month ago because of a divorce had no idea about Uncle sams attic. i emailed her and let her know how to get there and told her they ALWAYS have dirt cheap luggage (nothing fancy, but it gets the job done). she was so grateful and thankful. i didn't give her a handout or any money, just advice and she greatly appreciated it. i think that some of us are assuming that every cry for help is the same as begging for money. it isn't. when someone asks for help, maybe you know of a place that they don't or have been through the same situation. try giving some advice or direction before automatically assuming they are asking for a handout... 

Banannie --- 17 years ago -

We sure don't know other people's circumstances. My husband is not an E-3, but we're in a situation where we're raising our kids from our first marriages with no help from their parents in the US. Not an easy feat for anyone given the amount of money we all know it takes to raise children. I see these posts for E-3 and below and I think that it is so nice for people to help others out like that, but there are those of us, like myself, who don't fall into that category who would be so grateful as well. =) I do not however agree with people who whine about their situation. My husband and I love our lives and love being able to raise our children. We pinch pennies here and there and do our best to give our children everything and more. Thankfully I was raised by two people who taught me a thing or two about money... =) 

AznNvazn912 --- 17 years ago -

We all need help sometimes. SO no, its not wrong to ask. I think some people forget that their husbands/wives were e-3's at one point or another, so get off your effin high horse and have some compassion. 

Mr. Party Wagon --- 17 years ago -

actually, some people's husbands or wives could have started as O-1's instead, earning them much more money than an E-3. 

Wish you were me --- 17 years ago -

i dont think nothing is wrong and God forbid the person who is blasting them i think we are all family in this military community and we all serve our country some way or the other and just the same we should all help each other to b honest i think pay wise in the military sucks especially when u hav kids ..........yes no one told anyone to hav kids but shit happens........and i hope the ones posting bad things about them fall to theeir knees one day if they havent already (and yes please to take me on as im ready) but still i think they are just being a bag of scum bags to b downgrading ppl and if i could just know who it was ...i would definately give them my freebies that i am always willing to give .....E3 OR WHOEVER IF U NEED HELP JUST YELL ON OYS PPL LIKE ME ARE HERE TO HELP AS NO ONE KNOWS WHEN IT WILL BE THEM IN THE DILEMA.......THATS MY INTAKE .....AND ONE MORE THING THEY ARE NOT ASKING FOR HAND OUT NOTHING IS WRONG IN GIVING THEM WHAT YOU DONT WANT IF THEY WANT IT......ONE MANS TRASH IS ANOTHER MANS TREASURE 

April --- 17 years ago -

I don't think the original poster (you know, the one who's cornflakes somebody pissed in this morning) took into account that some of the people asking for help do not likely have their families nearby, and depending on how long they've been on the island they might not know enough people to have the luxury of a baby shower. We've been fortunate enough to not need to ask for help but I know if someone was willing to give me free unused diapers or used clothes that their baby grew out of I'd gladly take them. And half the stuff we had from when my twins were newborns were given to us FOR FREE by our wonderful military family and we in turn gave most of our things away when we no longer needed them. In fact, our Airman's Attic at our last base was completely free and unlimited. Unless these people are reselling items they receive for free for a profit or are asking for things like free video games, electronics or things of that nature, what is the problem? Especially when young mothers ask for help...the free items are going to help a BABY. It takes a good mother to get over her pride for the sake of her child and ask for help when she needs it. If the person who posted the original rude comment on OYS finds that annoying or feels that the effort it takes to scroll past the ads requesting free stuff is such an inconvenience, she should consider shopping elsewhere because I don't think her snotty opinion is going to effect what people post whatsoever. 

MOMZ --- 17 years ago -

Nothing wrong with asking for help. I don't get this whole conversation unless it's someone asking for help and they are completely rude about it or if they received items and turned around and sold it. I've been out of the net for the past few days. I should probably go back and read...lol. Anyhoo...more to follow. ;) 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I don't think there is anything wrong in asking for help either. Advise is just as generous as giving her free diapers, in my opinion. I do, however, find it funny that noone that posted those rude comments on OYS had the guts to post their views on here. 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

yeah i find that funny too. it's cause they were just being mean and afraid that someone might have a better point then them. . . or at least that is my story and I am sticking to it. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I agree. I had to go babysit and was hoping some of them posted on here.. I was looking forward to it while I was babysitting.. Oh well. You are still here zx9rgirl :P 

lilmama --- 17 years ago -

I don't have a problem helping anyone. In fact, I'd love to. I am just a little leary of doing it on OYS. I've heard too many wild stories of people getting ripped off, or people saying they are broke, need money, what not and then they go re-sell stuff. That's my only concern. 

Just another girl --- 17 years ago -

i dont have a problem helping out other people either. you dont know the persons financial history. i can tell you this that my husband and i have 3 kids and we are also supporting my mother in law. theres been time we've been a little low on money and people gave us free items like clothing for our kids. people shouldn't go off and say that its wrong to ask for free items because im sure at one point in your life you've done the same thing. so before you start to criticize someone maybe you should just step back and think has someone helped me out before and maybe you could do the same thing to help out another family 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

parenting
rant
rave

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground