Ok...I am not one to start arguments or step on toes but I am curious to know how others think about this.
I for one remember how it was when I was pregnant at 18 without the father in the picture. I also remember how much stuff was. BUT...I never asked for a hand out either. I got all that I needed without anyone giving it to me so why is it so difficult for a single active duty member or lower ranks to acquire things for a baby?
I even was pregnant with a second when my husband was a lower rank, and we still could afford to purchase baby items. I didn't keep my stuff from my first son so I had to buy it all new/used again.
I know everyones financial situation is different but it just bothers me when lower ranks or single active duty ask for donations.
I was once a 18 yr old and pregnant with no "Baby Daddy" around. I thankfully had my parents to help. I have no issues when someone hits hard times and needs to ask for donations. I doubt if they would if they didnt need things (it is kind of humiliating to have to ask for something because u can't afford it). We are on an Island and dont have regular yard sales and family here with us that can give us stuff.
My hubby is an E6 and has been in for 15 yrs and we hit hard times sometimes too. (With rank also comes more bills and dues). What bothers me is when they state there rank. I don't care if u are an O-1, SSGT, CPL. If u need help u need help. People dont have to donate if they think they are above it or themselves can not afford to donate at that time, or just don't want to donate for any reason. It really bothers me when people say "Free to E-3 or below," It is there stuff so I would never say anything as they are free to do what they want and don't deserve to hear my thoughts just because I disagree. But I tell u as E-6 single income spouse my hubby pays alot in SNCO dues a month not to mention awards and lunches etc for his young marines. SO all that extra $$$ goes right back to the pot so to speak. But sorry to go off on topic, I have no issue when people of any rank ask for donations. If I disagree with what they are asking or if they are being extremly picking about items I am offering then I just move on and offer it to someone else. But thats just my opinion, I hope I do not offend anyone.
The economy hasn't effected us in anyway, especially with us being over here. We get paid more living here. I know sometimes these things aren't planned, but once you find out, start buying things here and there from the time you get a positive till the baby is born.
If someone truly needs the help then I don't mind donating some of my daugther's old clothes and things like that but I hate to just give them to someone I don't know because I have no clue if they are going to go and re-sell them. I don't really give things away unless I personally know the family.
Yeah, if it is a personal friend, I don't mind giving my things away. I have had friends give me baby stuff with my second but I also didn't ask for it nor were we struggling but they just asked us to give it to someone else when we were done. I too gave it to a friend or I donated it to Good Will.
I did not say the economy affected us here, although it does because some of us invest and have lost $$$$, but to stay on topic, I said "like the economy now." If I have it to spare I will donate it is how I was raised. What u give out you will get back. If I donate something I leave it at that, if they turn around and sell it I like to think maybe they needed the $$ for some other nesesity (can't spell sorry), like gas to go to work etc. Just my thoughts
We're an e-3 single income family with three kids. we've had a boy, girl, boy so we had to start all over with each one and we still manage to make it.
i'm not saying it's everyone, but i've met single pregnant women in the military who just would rather buy expensive maternity clothes to look cute than prepare for their baby and then turn around and ask for handouts because "they just cant afford it with their salary." there is always a way, and if you truly need it then to hell with a pretense of pride, but i'm always weary of ppl asking for things. you never know.
Yeah I agree, I mean you can start to save as soon as you find out you are pregnant. You have 9 months. When I found out I was pregnant my husband and I would buy a bag or box of diapers and wipes every paycheck and we were stocked when we our daughter was born. We also bought some outfits here and there.
Like I said earlier, if I know the person and I know they need some extra help then I don't mind but if I don't know them I am weary as well.
Plus just because you dont have family here doesnt mean they dont or cant help. my mom had a baby shower in my honor back home and just sent me everything (although i think it was just an excuse to have a party, lol.)
My neighbors parents did the same thing, they did a "virtual" shower on webcam and then she sent all of the presents here :) Kind of a cool idea, I guess.
I did not say the economy affected us here
Didn't say you did, I said it didn't effect us, as in my husband and I because you said "like the economy now" has put people in over their heads.
That's cool though. I am just wanting to read everyone's opinions. Not going to get butt hurt if someone disagrees with me. Sometimes hearing others reasoning helps me understand it more so then I don't question as to why.
I am the type of person that usually gives things [for free] to either people I know or someone in my husband's Unit OR to an actual charity/donation type thing, like a Church or something similar. I don't mean to be rude; I am just iffy about giving things for free to people I don't know. I wouldn't type in a random Email address or walk up to a random person and ask for an item or anything and I guess I kind of see it the same way. Sorry, I hope I don't offend anyone. (:
I think that it is good for people to ask for help when they need it. People do have bills that carry over from being in the states. (at least my parents do, and my dad is fixing to be e7, been in for 19 years) Also, it isn't the easiest thing for spouses to get jobs, esp. if they are prego.
I think it takes guts to ask for help, it can be a hard thing to do.
they just want to be prepared for their child, i don't understand how that is a bad thing.
as long as they aren't asking for specifics (color, brand, etc) i say it is okay :) regaurdless of rank or if they are single.. just my opinion :)
Didn't say it was a bad thing, want to understand why I keep seeing these ads, "e-3 below couple expecting first baby and need donations," or "single active duty needing donations." Yeah, I know people have bills carried over. We have bills too but living here has allowed us to get above those bills and pay them down/off.
Like I said, I have been in that situation but with mine I didn't have that steady paycheck and was living with roommates and was still able to accumalate the items I needed to care for a baby. I was working at Blockbuster. I put stuff on layaway or bought from second hand stores. I managed.
Our money was tight when I found out I was prego with the second, but we focused on what we needed and did it without begging for help.
Maybe I am just someone that would rather work for something rather than look for an easy way out. *shrug*
some of the problems i've noticed has to do with poor money management, for example..on paydays i notice alot of people going out to dinner, thats at least 40-50 bucks right there, you can get a good amount of food at the commasary for that. Our first priority is pay bills,buy food then put some in saveings...but we rarely eat out, we save alot by just cooking. Add up how much is spent on beer and alcohol in one month! you'd be suprised..I see alot of these young first time moms to be wanting special furniture for there babies..honestly, the baby really don't care what color it's crib is..nor do they care what the fabric design is...they just want to be loved and fed...all those things are what the mother wants...get whats in your budget...then as you save up you can always make changes.
Didn't say it was a bad thing
I didn't say that you did.
Some people need to ask for help sometimes, I am glad you didn't have to. But like you said everyone is different. I am not going to be quick to judge, as I have not had a child yet, and don't know what could happen to me when I am in that situation. You never know, things come up.
Maybe people have more bills than you, or have just gotten here, maybe they don't have family they can turn to in the states, or friends to throw them a shower. Or they could be brand new to the military.. we don't know.
All I know is if someone needs help, I think they should ask.
I know my parents are struggling to pay some of their bills. My mom just started her job today, we have been here 7 months.
I am not talking about what you have and had not said or have or have not done.. I am just stating my opinion like you asked.
Yes, some people have poor money management. BUT they may have already "fixed" that since finding out they were having a baby. We don't know. And I am not going to judge. I am sure SOMEONE out there is willing to help.
So, what is the harm in asking, if you could really use the help.
Just keep in mind how you feel about the topic. It may be you that desperately needs the help one day.
I get what your saying Jamie. :)
For one, I am done having kids, no need for assistance in that part..lol. Secondly, I have learned to manage my money and have savings.
They have services on base that help with managing money if there is a problem with a family preparing for a baby.
I get what your saying Jamie. :)
For one, I am done having kids, no need for assistance in that part..lol. Secondly, I have learned to manage my money and have savings.
They have services on base that help with managing money if there is a problem with a family preparing for a baby.
Ok...the reason I don't see it the other way is because I have been through it. I had bills!! I had $40,000 in hospital bills from a four wheeler accident. I didn't have my parents to go to because they were struggling themselves. It was me being careless so it was my responsibility to take care of it.
I managed! So..I think what it all comes down to is money management and priorities.
If you have friends and family out to help, that is great and I would probably ask them for help if need be but I won't be asking random strangers on a website for donations. That is just me.
Now a different situation other than having a baby, for example, house burning down or major disaster; I would donate for that but just feel having a baby is something you should manage yourself.
Holly,
I thought you wanted to hear everyones opinions. It seems to me that anyone that disagrees you just keep arguing with or going back to well u did it and managed. So did I, but that does not make me better then someone else or less likely to help. In fact being as I struggled and went through it, it makes me want to help more if I can. Nobody knows this persons background ex. Could have been rapped and now preggo and against abortion, could have had there house back in the states burned down and now is broke and buying baby items is expensive, could have been a victim to money fraud and is now broke, I mean one just never knows. And there are alot of people out there like myself, that were raised if someone is asking for help and we can help, then help. It is called paying it forward, because one day I might be the one needing help (maybe not with baby items), but if I ever need help I would hope there are nice people that can help. ESPECIALLY in the military community. Also some people that ask for help are unaware of some of the programs out there structured to help mothers ex. WIC, BABY Budgetting class, etc. Sometimes they just need someone to help point them in the right drection. Please dont take offense this is just my opinion and not meant on an attack on your or anyone else. I am just posting my opinion like you asked people to do.
so why is it so difficult for a single active duty member or lower ranks to acquire things for a baby?
Don't know where this one is coming from but I agree, especially on island ... there are so many more resources than even in the states.
Can anyone point me in the direction of where this thread came about?
Thanks!
:)
I don't see myself as arguing. You all are throwing reasons out there that I have been through and know there are other ways. Now the other reasons you have mentioned are good valid reasons.
I ask now, if someone is asking for donations, would you ask as to why they are asking for donations? Would you be offended if someone asked why you were asking for donations if it was you?
I know you people don't know me, but to give you a heads up, I don't get offended to what people have to say and if that is your opinion you don't have to apologize( I have seen people saying sorry for their opinion). I truely do like to hear what you have to say and if you feel as though I am arguing with you, I am not. I can be convinced to think differently if I feel you have a valid response and so far Mrs. Taken you have had a pretty good one. I no way feel that I am better than anyone. I know people have hard times. But in this instance, majority of the time it is due to priorities.
so why is it so difficult for a single active duty member or lower ranks to acquire things for a baby?
Sasha, I was asking this from this thread because I saw someone asking for donations for a single active duty mother.
Sasha, I was asking this from this thread because I saw someone asking for donations for a single active duty mother.
Cand you post the link or bump that thread?
Thanks! It doesn't have to be today.