Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

selling "gifts"

who's talking here?

Wish you were me 1
Kitty 1
Jamie (Sake's momma) 1
Manna 1
Scrappy 2
Kathryn 1
banana4 2
Connors Mommy! 4
OkiCrafter 2
AirborneWife 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Connors Mommy! --- 17 years ago -

I dont have a BIG problem with it but I think that if someone gave you a gift and you never actually spent any money on it you shouldnt sell it for an insane amount..Like probably pretty cheap..unless its a nice or expensive item..bc then I think your being greedy..Am I wrong? 

AirborneWife --- 17 years ago -

mmmmmmmmm im thinking the same thing:) 

Connors Mommy! --- 17 years ago -

your uP! 

Connors Mommy! --- 17 years ago -

call me i gotta talk to you LOl 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

I dont think you should sell a gift at all. I think you should pay it forward. We were given a fisher price cradle swing and matching papa san bouncy chair and together those 2 were right at 200 bucks. Once Im done I will give them away because they were given to me. I just really truly believe in Karma and doing good deeds. I think its just tacky to sell something you didnt pay for. 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

I'm giving away stuff that we got for our wedding gifts. Duplicates, things that I didn't really need because I got one that I already liked. I don't see a point in making a profit on something that I was given. 

AirborneWife --- 17 years ago -

call me i gotta talk to you LOl girl, are ya still up? i was about to call but u wrote this an hour ago and dont wanna wake up derek or connor. 

OkiCrafter --- 17 years ago -

I must stand alone on this one, but I think its fine to sell something you were given. We were given a used car for our wedding and after a year we no longer needed it. We didn't know what to do with it, and didnt know anyone who wanted or needed it. I called the people who gave it to us and they told us "SELL IT. We GAVE it to you to do what you wish with it." I think selling a gift is the same as regifting an item. If you were going to spend $20 on an item for a birthday gift, but you gave a regifted item instead ... You saved $20, but at the same time, you still GAVE that item away. same same yes no? When we were first married, I ain't gonna lie, we were broke. I sold and returned quite a bit of our wedding gifts just to get by. Thankfully, that was 10 years ago and we are lucky enough to be able to pay it forward with other things now. We were blessed to have a wedding and receive gifts, but what good is a crystal platter if you have no food to put on it? 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I agree with just me :) 

Manna --- 17 years ago -

I think it depends on the gift, and why you're selling it in the first place. If you're selling it just to make room, then I believe in the whole Karma issue... but if you're selling items because you absolutely need the money (and not for that new coach bag) then you have to do what you have to do... 

Wish you were me --- 17 years ago -

Just me I agree with you totally ....i personally dont resell gifts as ii always put them down and regive them to others who might need such items but at the same time no one should care what people do with their gifts my mother always say ..you give it away then its not urs or your responsibility to seek info on what they do with it why becos its now theirs and people have a right to do what ever they need to do with their things let it be their judgment.......im a little off but being here on okinawa taught me a lot about different people in life and something are now petty to worry abut like my husband says " you give someone something for free and they sold it hey u never know if they really needed that money and in the same breath u'll never know if they didnt need it so let it be their Karma just keep in mind u did a great thing" 

Scrappy --- 17 years ago -

I look at it like this, they thought enough of you to give it to you even though they could have made money selling it...therefore why should you make a profit off of a nice gesture? To each their own though. Different opinions make the world go round. 

banana4 --- 17 years ago -

I don't know, maybe I'm thinking of gifts differently. I can't think of a time, other than our wedding, where we were given any real "gifts". Our family sends my daughter clothes sometimes that end up either too small for her by the time they get her or sometimes they're kind of ugly. I don't have endless storage & can't keep things that are no use to us & I don't have any friends with kids her age to pass it on to. So I sell the item for very cheap. (usually like $5 for a $30 item, $3 for a $20 item, etc) If someone was seriously thinking of you though & thought they picked out the "perfect gift" it might be a little rude to resell it. But like random kids birthday gifts and stuff. That item was given to your kid, if they don't like it or can't use it. Sell it for cheap & use the money to buy them something they do want. 

OkiCrafter --- 17 years ago -

Exactly Banana, I don't consider "hand me downs" as gifts. I would never sell clothes, baby stuff or anything that anyone has passed on to me because they knew I needed it. I would however sell or return actual gifts if I didnt like them or need them and use the money to buy something I wanted. I would think that the giver would like for me to do that. JMO 

banana4 --- 17 years ago -

Oh yeah, I've been given free clothes here. Each time, what we didn't want or need I passed on for free to other people. The clothes my family sent were new, still with tags..just not something she would be able to wear & I didn't want to waste the $ to ship them back & be like "uhhh, can you send something else?" lol! So I just sold them for cheap & used all the money from a few items to buy her like 1 thing. 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

I have to say I have had moments when I sit on the fence with this. I do not like to resell gifts as most of the time they are from the heart or they are something that was meaningful or helpful in some way. . . That is the way that it would be in the ideal sense of things mostly my side of the family. Gifts are from the heart and new things that are useful. The problem here comes from the husband's side of the family. "Gifts" being things that literally take up space and are not helpful or useful to anyone. These are things like blankets that have been sitting in a basement for years in a new package but price marked from a now out of business store or a NEW in the box waffle iron when neither of us eat waffles at least not home made ones because they are not worth the time to make in our opinion. These gifts usually get sold. The reason is because we then take the money from whatever it was that was given to us and then put it towards something like car repairs or JCI/Insurance fees. . . . or maybe something else like a new pair of shoes or something. Now when it comes to things like clothes that we get and don't fit into or things that could literally HELP other people we usually give it away. I think it all depends on what you are getting for a "gift". 

Connors Mommy! --- 17 years ago -

just me I totally agree with you bc you gave the gift away to another person not sold it to another person..banana i also agree with you that when people give hand me downs you hand them down with your done with them! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

charity
humor
okinawa
oys

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground