WHY?
Because the government feels it must protect us from ourselves.
I don't smoke but I hate to see laws that violate the most basic freedom of choice.
They are waitin for Obama to sign it- which I am sure he will- but he smokes too lol...
" Legislation was introduced to Congress this week by Rep Henry Waxman (D-CA) that would subject tobacco products to regulation by the FDA. This sounds like a good thing, coming from a revered public health advocate. The truth is that if cigarettes were evaluated by the same safety standards that FDA routinely applies to other products for human consumption, cigarettes would be immediately banned. That's not how things will proceed under HR 1256.
The bill represents a compromise between Philip Morris and some of the more 'reasonable' anti-tobacco groups, including Center for Tobacco-Free Kids and the American Cancer Society. These organizations have a history of promoting legislation that offers incremental progress immediately in exchange for guarantees that block more comprehensive restrictions long into the future.
Specifically, the present bill drastically limits the way that cigarettes can be regulated by FDA; at the same time, it will impose much stricter standards on nicotine gum, patches, smokeless tobacco, and other smoking-cessation aids. The American Council on Science and Health says, "the legislation offered by Chairman Waxman will, in fact, have the unintended consequence of making it harder for smokers to stop quitting."
(Background: it is not the nicotine in cigarettes that causes cancer. Ex-smokers who maintain their nicotine dose on patches or even with spit tobacco have in fact substantially reduced their risk of mortality, and, of course, they no longer impose a burden on people around them with passive tobacco smoke.)
As an alternative, Congressmen Steve Buyer (R-IN) and Mike McIntyre (D-NC) have introduced a clean tobacco control bill that offers no restrictions that will slow progress in the future.
Now that Bush is out of the White House and Congress is in Democratic hands, the tobacco industry has much to fear from a resumption of a 40-year legislative campaign to reduce tobacco use in the country and to protect non-smokers in public areas. Let's make sure that this opportunity is not squandered.
Understanding Philip Morris's support for Govt Regulation of Tobacco
Here is a specific critique of the bill prepared by Mike Cummings:
These are very serious ... but fixable ... problems. The health community should see that these issues are resolved, then rally behind the improved bill.
* Precluding the FDA's authority to ban any class of tobacco product. Cigarettes and other combustion forms of tobacco are the real problem, and probably should be banned or at least phased out of existence.
* Precluding the FDA's authority to eliminate nicotine from tobacco products. Combustion tobacco products such as cigarettes cannot be made safer through manipulation of the tobacco or product design unless they are made nonaddictive.
* All evidence points to nicotine as the primary feature of tobacco products that cause them to be addictive and thus dangerous to use. For combustion tobacco products at the very least, the FDA ought to have the authority to remove nicotine and other design elements that make these combustion tobacco products unreasonably dangerous.
* Precluding the FDA's authority to remove additives that are nontoxic.
* The FDA ought to have full authority to remove all additives used in tobacco products regardless of their toxicity. Many addictives that are not toxic in their own right, such as menthol, contribute to the appeal of the product in ways that reinforce exposure to other toxins found in tobacco.
* Mandating tobacco industry representation on the oversight committee. This provision makes no sense. Due to an obvious conflict of interest, drug companies are precluded by the FDA in making judgments about the safety and efficacy of their drugs. Tobacco manufacturers should not be permitted to have special authority to influence the rules that the government makes about the labeling, health and safety regulations of tobacco products. This provision would also make the United States noncompliant with one of the key articles in the WHO FCTC.
* Preempting state and local regulation of tobacco products. The FDA ought to set the minimum standards for regulation and allow local and state health authorities to have the ability of implementing stronger regulations if such regulations are deemed necessary to protect the publics' health."
They are waitin for Obama to sign it- which I am sure he will- but he smokes too lol...
Does he really?? I did not know that.. it was not in his campaign....
But then again alot of the sh*t he is now doing was not either...
Here is link: New smoking bill
But here are a few quotes from it...
to drastically curtail ads that glorify tobacco and to ban flavored products aimed at spreading the habit to young people.
President Barack Obama, who has spoken of his own struggle to quit smoking, said he was eager to sign the legislation, and the House planned a vote for Friday.
The legislation, one of the most dramatic anti-smoking initiatives since the surgeon general's report, would give the Food and Drug Administration authority to regulate the content, marketing and advertising of cigarettes and other tobacco products.
First of all you can not believe anything you see on the internet in pictures as factual information I hate to say it but the fact is anything can be doctored today especially when it makes people want to think that a person is a hypocrite. . . . .
Taking away flavored tobacco isn't anything new either. This is an issue that happened in the past when they had flavored chewing tobacco. It was banned because of it's appeal to young children.
Because the government feels it must protect us from ourselves.
Not here to start anything but it could be to protect the ones who dont smoke from the ones who do....cos some people who smoke have no respect for others....Some mothers often drag themselves to the play ground smoking which pisses me off as each time i take my daughter she ends up wheezing...so now i make her stay in wow such a fun time inside huh....
yeah one more thing and for the ones who live in the towers and sit in their living room and smoke knowing that we have shred ventilation fun and considerate huh
First of all you can not believe anything you see on the internet in pictures as factual information
True. But he has admitted to smoking in interviews but says he won't be smoking in the white house. Maybe his attempts at quitting are behind the new smoking laws.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/28097910/
Not here to start anything but it could be to protect the ones who dont smoke from the ones who do....cos some people who smoke have no respect for others....Some mothers often drag themselves to the play ground smoking which pisses me off as each time i take my daughter she ends up wheezing...so now i make her stay in wow such a fun time inside huh....
I am going to have to agree with you here. See the thing is that there are people out there like myself that choose not to smoke because of the problems that it can cause and because I like to remain healthy. You might not realize it but smoking does release deadly chemicals into the air. Involving the FDA which is basically what this bill is about is going to allow them to determine which chemicals are most hazardous and try to regulate their use so that you as a smoker do not continue to suck in any more of it. I honestly don't see how a smoker can see that as a negative affect.
True. But he has admitted to smoking in interviews but says he won't be smoking in the white house. Maybe his attempts at quitting are behind the new smoking laws.
Very true very true, but don't forget he doesn't come up with the laws he gets presented them. And I am just stating the fact. Too many people today believe all of what they see and that is a mistake unfortunately. :-)
but EVERY parent isn't like that! I don't smoke around my daughter or around anyone elses kid. i understand that yall choose not to smoke but it seems like yall are bashing every parent that smokes! I would Never smoke at a playground! there are certain places which it is ok to smoke but not where chrildren play.
but don't forget he doesn't come up with the laws he gets presented them
Right. I meant that his quitting is his reason for backing them, not that he came up with them.
some people who smoke have no respect for others
She said that "some parents" not all. No one is bashing every single person who smokes as one of those parents.
but EVERY parent isn't like that! I don't smoke around my daughter or around anyone elses kid. i understand that yall choose not to smoke but it seems like yall are bashing every parent that smokes! I would Never smoke at a playground! there are certain places which it is ok to smoke but not where chrildren play.
I agree with you 100% and I am by no means bashing anyone that smokes just stating facts about cigarettes and harmful chemicals. And sadly just because you would not do it does not mean that it is not a problem. There is a similar seat belt situation.
The fact is what they are trying to do is protect you who do choose to smoke and those who are around you from the nasty dangerous things that the cigarette companies are putting into your cigarettes most of the time without you noticing. They are not trying to take away your freedom.
but EVERY parent isn't like that
It's not necessarily about parents. It's about ANYONE who smokes. Many, many, many people are extremely inconsiderate about where they smoke. I know some of you will jump on here and say how considerate you are-fine. But you are in the EXTREME minority.
I can't wait for the Air Force to ban smoking in all public spaces on base, including outdoor areas where people congregate.
And, ANY amount of smoking is detrimental to your children, even if you don't do it directly around them. The hazardous chemicals in smoke linger on your clothes, your hair, in your car. Plus, you are then sending the message to your child that smoking is an "ok" thing, when really, from a health-wise standpoint, it's not.
Interesting... I did not know that. You learn something new everyday! First of all you can not believe anything you see on the internet in pictures as factualTrue. But he has admitted to smoking in interviews but says he won't be smoking in the white house. Maybe his attempts at quitting are behind the new smoking laws.
The fact that he smokes was covered during the campaign. It was brought up for his stance against big tobacco. He admitted to being a smoker and that he had stopped once before...others mentioned this as a weakness since he stopped and then started up again.
About the flavored cigs. One idea behind it is that flavored cigs help to target children (teens). By eliminating the flavored ones, they suspect teen smoking will go down. Think about it...if all you could get were Lucky Strikes, would you necessarily smoke?
but but i think smokes that have nothing bad in them will taste like butt
I think that's what the government is hoping because that may cause people to quit.