Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Taking binky away...

who's talking here?

MissyLouWho 1
courtney 1
Master Procrastinator 1
Krystle 2
Nobia 1
*~Butterfly Blevins~* 8
mwr885 1
Nicole 1
Addy3 1
Sara 2
leavingokisoon 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

So I feel like a horrible mom...as my kid is screaming because I put her to bed without binky...she has been crying for like 20 mins now...I wish it was like Sunday and she was ok now without it...LOL :o) She is breaking my heart... 

Krystle --- 17 years ago -

Be strong, Its for the best... Love hurts :) 

Sara --- 17 years ago -

How old is she? I'm regretting giving my daughter one. She just started taking one...at 7 months. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

Don't worry you can talk all about it to her and her therapist in a few years. Just Joking! I know how you feel we had to do the same thing to our son. Be Strong!! 

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

I know love hurts...she is my love!!! She is almost 13 months...and has two teeth...she is slowing stopping crying...I hear here every now and again... 

Sara --- 17 years ago -

My little one started taking it when she started teething...Two teeth came in the same day, and the doctor even told me it was good for her when she teeths...she won't take it always, although sometimes I wish she would! Good luck....it'll get easier... 

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

She don't really use it until she takes a nap or bed time...but I was so attached to mine and I would just rather do it now then have a harder time later...plus being a dental assistant and seeing what it can do to their teeth...it is just KILLING me hurt crying like she is...she stops then like freakes out...LOL can you tell I'm a first time mom! :o) 

Krystle --- 17 years ago -

My sister used a binky for the longest and when my mom took it away from her she started sucking her thumb and continued til she was 12. She ended up getting a gap and had to wear braces for 2 years during which she stopped. 

Nobia --- 17 years ago -

Aww, we went through this with my oldest. But oddly enough she kept finding them. Like she had hidden them for safe keeping knowing the day was coming. Eventually she got over it. Luckly, or not depending on how you look at it. My youngest refused binkies, bottles, even sippie cups. I nursed that boy for 2 years before one day he just decided he was done. 

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

yeah it is just hard...she is still crying...just not a whole lot...I know she will cry herself to sleep...and before I know it she won't need it anymore...I just hate her little cry...breaks my heart!!!! Sniffle Sniffle 

courtney --- 17 years ago -

We just recently got rid of "binkie" within the past 2 weeks. I lost it and decided that it was time that it disappeared FOREVER. It takes time, but she will eventually get over it. 

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

She has stopped crying...thank goodness...I wonder how long it will take her to cry herself to sleep tomorrow night???? I feel so horrible.... 

Addy3 --- 17 years ago -

When I was a nanny for two different families we tried different things when taking the binky away. The first family we cut the rubber part of the binky. So when he put it in his mouth and tried sucking on it, nothing happened. He searched the whole house for a "working" binky to satisfy him, but when he didn't find one, he stopped. Second family we rounded up all the binkies (mind you she had them hidden all over the house) and put them in a ziploc bag. We then went to Disney World where she gave them all to Mickey Mouse so that he could give them to the new babies he met. She cried herself to sleep on the way home once she realized they were gone, did ask for one the next day at nap time, but when she remembered what we did with them, she didn't ask again. I know it sounds somewhat easy, and each kid is different, but it worked. Each of them were around 2 at the time. 

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

I have never thought about cutting them...if she don't let go this way, I will try that...she is asleep...I haven't heard her for about 30 mins...we shall see how tomorrow goes! Thanks for everyone's advice and comments...I appreciate them!!! 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

We got rid of the paci in stages. First to go was daytime. Then naptime. Then nighttime. My son didn't really have too hard of a time with it, although he was older. We dropped daytime at about 19-20 months, naptime around 22 months and nighttime at about 24 months. For me, it didn't bother me that he had it longer-it was a source of comfort to him. And, I didn't want him to start sucking his thumb instead-that's harder to break. And, it involved fairly minimal tears, since we waited until he was more "ready" to give it up. 

MissyLouWho --- 17 years ago -

My friend did it the same way (cutting the rubber part), and that worked. Nothing else seemed to work and she would just cry and cry. Only prob was my friend's daughter had hidden them around the house, but once all of them were found (and cut) then she was ok because they were "broken" and it wasnt her mom's fault. I think she was over 2 years old when she decided to do this. 

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

yeah if this don't work maybe I'll cut them tomorrow she is up again crying...but not much just a little fussing here and there...poor kid...I feel so horrible I know I keep saying it but I just feel bad... 

*~Butterfly Blevins~* --- 17 years ago -

we made it through the night fine...she is up earler than before but that is fine with me...we will see how tonight goes before I try cutting them, she is almost 13 months old and has some teeth so...let's hope this just gets easier and easier... 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

You know how I did it? I cut off the tip and every day I'd cut it a little shorter until she didn't want it anymore. :D 

leavingokisoon --- 17 years ago -

be lucky my daughter is 3 1/2 and she hides them. so she goes to be without one but has one in the morning 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground