Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Should this specific guy get out of prison?

who's talking here?

JenMBH 1
Chancey♥ 2
mwr885 1
Kat 5
lilloudymouth 2
wendy 1
kc; Sooners Lovin! 2
Julie 4
JustMe 1
Troublemaker 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Should this specific guy get out of prison?

Okay, the other poll made me think of a case specific to a friend of mine. His Father was a cop. He came up on a group of kids about 16 with drugs one night and one of them decided he wasn't going to jail so he shot him in the head before even being approached. My friends father wasn't aware they had drugs on them, he pulled over because they happened to have their emergency lights on while standing next to their car. He called it in before getting out that he was assisting someone with car trouble. Should that guy get out of prison?

Yes Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
No Vote
 
 96.0% (24)
Not sure Vote
 
 4.0% (1)
Julie --- 17 years ago -

Okay, the other poll made me think of a case specific to a friend of mine. His Father was a cop. He came up on a group of kids about 16 with drugs one night and one of them decided he wasn't going to jail so he shot him in the head before even being approached. My friends father wasn't aware they had drugs on them, he pulled over because they happened to have their emergency lights on while standing next to their car. He called it in before getting out that he was assisting someone with car trouble. Should that guy get out of prison? 

Chancey♥ --- 17 years ago -

No he shouldnt, that was cold blooded murder. 

kc; Sooners Lovin! --- 17 years ago -

NO WAY DUDE. That's cold out murder. I believe he should never get out of prison. His life should be OVER. 

wendy --- 17 years ago -

cold blooded murder. I completely agree. 

lilloudymouth --- 17 years ago -

no that kid has no concience and would probably murder again 

Julie --- 17 years ago -

he got out about 12 years ago. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

But should you forever be condemed for something you did when you were 16? Just playing devil advocate a little. I think what he did was wrong and I hope he burns in hell. but I gotta wonder if he should pay for the mistake for the next 80 years. Maybe he will learn his lesson? 

Julie --- 17 years ago -

I think what he did was wrong and I hope he burns in hell. but I gotta wonder if he should pay for the mistake for the next 80 years. Maybe he will learn his lesson? It's been awhile since he's gotten out. I know the cops keep a close eye on him or at least they did. I don't think he's done anything since. But I beleive he should have never gotten out. I'm a firm believer in a life for a life. Even if it doesn't mean the death penalty. He's now getting the chance to do and live the life my friends father won't. I don't believe anyone can pay that debt back. Even if he is a changed person now. I hope he burns one day too! 

Kat --- 17 years ago -

It's tough because as much as I want to say he should never get out I do think that mislead children at such a young age make mistakes that they might not have made with the proper amount of discipline. Would I call him a cold blooded killer? Maybe not, maybe just a stupid scared teen down the wrong path? Who knows. 

Chancey♥ --- 17 years ago -

its definitly hard. i can see both sides... 

Kat --- 17 years ago -

Don't get me wrong I definitely sympathize for the lost life. There is nothing you can do to get that back, but playing devil's advocate here for a moment myself, being in that type of profession and I do have family members in that profession, you come to realize that things like this could be a reality, just as it would of a military member. It is sad but very difficult to assess. 

JustMe --- 17 years ago -

do think that mislead children at such a young age make mistakes that they might not have made with the proper amount of discipline You know... I honestly don't have any sympathy. People can make their own decisions. It doesn't matter how crappy of an environment you are raised in, you make your own choices on who you want to become and what you do with your life. I don't think he should have ever been released. It was cold blooded murder. period. 

Kat --- 17 years ago -

You know... I honestly don't have any sympathy. People can make their own decisions. It doesn't matter how crappy of an environment you are raised in, you make your own choices on who you want to become and what you do with your life. I don't think he should have ever been released. It was cold blooded murder. period.  I totally respect your opinion however coming from the inner city myself there are a lot of people who are young, mislead and at such a young age don't know any better who with the proper discipline and going to through the proper channels turn out to have values and morals just like any other person. If you raise a child not knowing the proper way to conduct yourself then they don't have the tools to make themselves a better person and I am sorry but a 16 year old needs GUIDANCE be it from the state putting them in a program detaining them or a parent. I am sorry but if a 5 or 10 year old were to pick up a gun and shoot someone killing them would you consider them able to be prisoned for life? Everyone makes mistakes, especially kids, some more drastic then others although to some kids it's "oops I drove the car into a ditch" some have harder lifestyles then others and it's a much more severe consequence. They SHOULD PAY for their actions! Don't get me wrong! I just think that after X number of years they should have the ability to redeem themselves. 

Julie --- 17 years ago -

I totally respect your opinion however coming from the inner city myself there are a lot of people who are young, mislead and at such a young age don't know any better who with the proper discipline and going to through the proper channels turn out to have values and morals just like any other person. If you raise a child not knowing the proper way to conduct yourself then they don't have the tools to make themselves a better person and I am sorry but a 16 year old needs GUIDANCE be it from the state putting them in a program detaining them or a parent. I am sorry but if a 5 or 10 year old were to pick up a gun and shoot someone killing them would you consider them able to be prisoned for life? Everyone makes mistakes, especially kids, some more drastic then others although to some kids it's "oops I drove the car into a ditch" some have harder lifestyles then others and it's a much more severe consequence. They SHOULD PAY for their actions! Don't get me wrong! I just think that after X number of years they should have the ability to redeem themselves. This wasn't the inner city for the record it was a small town in GA. His father worked at the Levis factory and I think his mother did too. But even the inner city child knows what's right and wrong. That's why they run. They know what they did was agaisnt the law they just don't care. I agree it has a lot to do with how they are raised but like someone said above they have the power to make their own choices. 

kc; Sooners Lovin! --- 17 years ago -

I'm sorry, but if you kill someone, then why should you get a second chance? That dead guy's life is over, no more chances for him. 

Kat --- 17 years ago -

This wasn't the inner city for the record it was a small town in GA. His father worked at the Levis factory and I think his mother did too. But even the inner city child knows what's right and wrong. That's why they run. They know what they did was agaisnt the law they just don't care. I agree it has a lot to do with how they are raised but like someone said above they have the power to make their own choices.  There are bad people everywhere and no not all inner city kids run. I guess I just feel that although yes they do have the power to make their own decisions children don't always make the right ones for whatever reason. We say when kids are too young to make a decision to get married, we say when kids are too young to decide they want to become pregnant and make those life choices I don't see how in this case that child is any more mature to make those decisions then the people in the examples above. . . but that's just me. **I'm sorry, but if you kill someone, then why should you get a second chance? That dead guy's life is over, no more chances for him. ** Lots of people loose their lives in the line of duty every day. It's a hard fact to face and it is sad for those family members who do loose a loved one. The fact of the matter is there are people out there who do much worse things habitually. This kid is going to have the police force up his a$$ for the rest of his life AS HE SHOULD! And if he is out of line again, he will pay. Although it was a loss of a life the court granted him another chance for whatever reason. We can sit and debate about it constantly but it's not going to bring the life of that fallen gentleman back that is hard to swallow for anyone. The fact is he was doing his job, serving his time trying to keep people safe. All we can do is take it as a lesson to keep our kids in line so this type of thing doesn't happen to anyone else. 

Troublemaker --- 17 years ago -

I say yes because he was a minor at the time. If he was of age then I'd say let him rot forever but I'm a believer in giving kids the chance to change after of course they get their prison time but they should not be held to the same standard as an adult imho. But of course this would depend on all the details of the case and background of the kid. 

Troublemaker --- 17 years ago -

Also, if kids are held to adult standards and are adult enough for adult punishment than they should get adult rights and priveledges. Anything less is hyprocritical. 

JenMBH --- 17 years ago -

I totally respect your opinion however coming from the inner city myself there are a lot of people who are young, mislead and at such a young age don't know any better who with the proper discipline and going to through the proper channels turn out to have values and morals just like any other person. I agree with you on this a lot. BUT it's still hard for me to say that he should have been able to get out. Maybe after being in for 20 years or something then yes, if a board thinks he is okay to get out. But he would have had to go through a lot of counseling first. I dunno, it's hard because he was just a kid but he did take a life. 

Troublemaker --- 17 years ago -

I grew up in the projects. Parents on drugs, a bunch of different crap. I've been in trouble as a kid, nothing like this. In every case I've seen of teens messing up was 99% parents fault. Either substance abuse or just bad situations all around. 

Troublemaker --- 17 years ago -

So again yes kids should be punished. But rehabilitation should be the aim because they are kids. I believe they can change. 

lilloudymouth --- 17 years ago -

I think for him to be able to murder in that quick and cold of a manner it shows you he isnt mentally stable. If he wasnt mentally stable then he sure as hell isnt going to be 12 years later after living locked up with a whole bunch of inmates who are in there for the same things. So many people think that most of these guys learn such a big lesson in prison. The truth is they are walking around the yard smiling and laughing. Having drugs brought in through visitation, pretending life is grand. He is probably more messed up now than he was when he went in. 

Kat --- 17 years ago -

I think that with more of the facts and evidence more can be determined such how far away was the shot taken from? Was it a "lucky" shot (or rather unlucky) that happened to hit the officer in the head or was this kid an amazingly skilled marksman? From what we know it wasn't a shot at point blank, his under developed thought process might have been to fire off a shot to scare him away we don't know that. I do not think that many people change 100% when they go to prison just as I think a child molester will always want to molest children regardless how long he is serving time. I just think that we are basing things off really what is nothing but basic facts. My feeling is that a cold blooded murder is someone like the kids in Columbine that go into a school knowing and wanting to kill other people just because they are black, white, hispanic, christian, non christian or just because it feel right. If he isn't mentally stable, then he should be able to seek treatment which the court would have decided for him and then they would go from there. 

Troublemaker --- 17 years ago -

Well the columbine shooters were victims as well but that's another story. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground