My mother-in-law is wanting to purchase us a swing for her first grandchild and has me looking at ones that we want.
We tried out the lambs and dreams by Fisher Price one in the store and absolutely loved it but after reading the reviews, I am scared. A baby fell out because the seat is connected by one screw? That's crazy!! We also are looking at the papasan cradle swing as well but again, there are scary reviews on it.
For all the mothers, which did you use? Did you like it? Why? Was it safe? Did it rock so hard the base moved? I have heard that to be a common problem..
I have the ocean wonders swing and the blue and green one from the PX. I love both of them but the ocean wonders is still to big for my little guys. The seat doesn't recline enough and their little heads fall forward. However I did use it with Jacob and he loved it. It seemed to me like it holds more weight than the other swings too.
Hmmmm I will have to go check it out:)
I'm really disappointed about the lambs and dreams swing because we both really liked it in the store.. But I don't want anything that is dangerous. What confuses me the most is that the same exact reviews were posted for both of the swings we liked..odd?
I have the Fisher Price Nature's Touch Cradle Swing. I like that you can swing it either way. Also there is a mirror on top (that my baby LOVES) and a mobile. It does rock if the base isn't set up correctly. I really like it though and I'm glad we have it.
*edited* I looked for the swing again to see what reviews other gave it for you, and the price has come down a lot.
But I don't want anything that is dangerous. What confuses me the most is that the same exact reviews were posted for both of the swings we liked..odd?
When I was looking at swings, I went through the same thing. By nature, swings aren't 100% safe and I think it will be very difficult to find a swing that NOBODY has had a problem with (whether it be manufacturer error or user error).
ChiTown: yes you are very right. Almost all of them had some sort of issue with them. I think I got freaked out by the story about the baby falling out of the swing you know?
That's why you always buckle the baby in, and once your baby can roll over, you don't let them use it anymore. I think some parents want to use swings and that sort of thing as a babysitter and forget that they also have to watch their kid and use common sense. Don't get me wrong, I know that there are legit problems with some swings, but it's important that you follow the directions. Swings, bouncers, and other baby equiptment is great when it is used right.
Oh no, the review said because the base of the seat is bolted in with only ONE screw, the seat fell off with her son in it and he landed on his face..isn't that crazy? I totally know what you're saying though. There is nothing wrong with sitting him in the swing while you vacuum the living room or something but I've heard of moms leavig the baby on the swing downstairs while she is on the shower upstairs..alot can happen in 30 minutes.
Casey, I really like that. About how long did your little one use the swing for?
Caitlin,
Every single baby product will have SOMETHING negative that has happened while someone is using it.
EVERY SINGLE ONE. I promise. :)
Take a deep breath and relax. Most of those issues are user error.
Many people don't buckle in a baby when they think the baby "can't move." This is incredibly dangerous-all babies can move, lol. Sometimes, they manage to flail about just enough that they fall out, off, etc of things.
You are very smart to do research-but also remember to use your common sense. Always, always, buckle your baby in to whatever it is-and buckle them snugly. It does not help to have your child buckled into a bouncy seat/swing/car seat/high chair if the straps are so loose your baby can slip out of it.
You will do just fine-everyone is nervous, especially with that first baby. The important thing is to choose good products (ones that don't have current recalls), use them properly- every single time, and periodically check for both recalls, and for any issues (screws coming loose, fraying straps, etc.)
I hope that helped make you feel a bit better-it can be very overwhelming navigating the world of baby products.
Oh no, the review said because the base of the seat is bolted in with only ONE screw, the seat fell off with her son in it and he landed on his face..isn't that crazy?
Caitlin, it's very possible that they didn't have it screwed in properly, and didn't check every so often to make sure it was still tight. :)
Oh Nicole, thank you:) I am trying very very hard not to get freaked out by certain things that I see and hear through word of mouth but jeeeeeez, everything has something wrong with it.
I think I am very nervous that there will be an error that I make (or my husband) and she gets hurt. Especially with only having experience with babies through babysitting. I don't really remember my brother being born so I didn't get that extra practice.
I am looking at reviews on everything but in the end you are right, everything has had something bad happen with it at one time or another..I just don't want that something to happen to us:)
Caitlin, it's very possible that they didn't have it screwed in properly, and didn't check every so often to make sure it was still tight. :)
yep, you very well can be right:)
I have the sweet peace soothing center by Graco (my car seat actually can snap into it too). I have some friends with the same swing and they swear by it.
Oh no, the review said because the base of the seat is bolted in with only ONE screw, the seat fell off with her son in it and he landed on his face..isn't that crazy?
Caitlin, it's very possible that they didn't have it screwed in properly, and didn't check every so often to make sure it was still tight. :)
This. If you like the swing. Don't let one bad review freak you out, Most likely it was user error not the fact that it was held together by only one screw. The parents probably were not using it correctly to begin with or did not follow the instructions when they put it together properly. If a swing or any other baby product has a recall that is the most important thing to look at. Not whether someone else liked it. Since everyone's personal preference is different for different things :-) good luck and you will be just fine with what ever one you decide to buy. Just make sure you follow the directions and don't take any shortcuts when putting together your baby's things and use it properly :-)
.I just don't want that something to happen to us:)
If you are careful, you will decrease your chance, but remember that you are human. You will make mistakes. You will (unintentionally) do something that hurts your child. It's a given. You might bump her head one day, or clip a nail too short, or a million and one other things. It happens. It happens to all of us-and if someone tells you they've never, ever done anything that caused pain in their child, they are lying to you.
You do the best you can, and you make sure you "follow the rules" when it comes to safety stuff, and then you just relax.
:)
MG, thats almost the same one were were looking at it..The other one that we were looking at is this one.
http://www.target.com/Fisher-Price-Lil-Lamb-Dream-Swing/dp/B0018Z6910/ref=br_1_1?ie=UTF8&frombrowse=1&searchView=grid5&searchNodeID=1041926&searchRank=pmrank&searchPage=1&searchSize=30
and this one..which is almost the same one you posted.
http://www.target.com/Butterfly-Garden-Papasan-Cradle-Swing/dp/B000I5Q19Q/ref=br_1_12?ie=UTF8&frombrowse=1&searchView=grid5&searchNodeID=1041926&node=1041926&searchRank=pmrank&searchPage=1&searchSize=30&id=Butterfly%20Garden%20Papasan%20Cradle%20Swing
I am torn between the 2 in the end I guess..
Caitlin, go with the neutral one. The Butterfly Garden one is beautiful, but you don't want to have to buy another if you have a boy next....they are so expensive!!
If you are careful, you will decrease your chance, but remember that you are human. You will make mistakes. You will (unintentionally) do something that hurts your child. It's a given. You might bump her head one day, or clip a nail too short, or a million and one other things. It happens. It happens to all of us-and if someone tells you they've never, ever done anything that caused pain in their child, they are lying to you.
You do the best you can, and you make sure you "follow the rules" when it comes to safety stuff, and then you just relax.
my mom fell asleep with me on her chest one time and i fell on to the floor off of the couch:) I plan to breastfeed for AS LONG as I can so I am scared that the sleepless nights will kind of get to me and I may fall asleep with her latched on or on my chest or roll over onto her or something like that. But you're right..In the end, we all make mistakes.
This. If you like the swing. Don't let one bad review freak you out, Most likely it was user error not the fact that it was held together by only one screw. The parents probably were not using it correctly to begin with or did not follow the instructions when they put it together properly. If a swing or any other baby product has a recall that is the most important thing to look at. Not whether someone else liked it. Since everyone's personal preference is different for different things :-) good luck and you will be just fine with what ever one you decide to buy. Just make sure you follow the directions and don't take any shortcuts when putting together your baby's things and use it properly :-)
oh yes, it very well could have been their fault in the end. My husband and I are definitely going to make sure screws are tight enough and wont "chince" on things when it comes to her safety. Now is not the time to rush:)
I'm quite sure this is the case. You'd be surprised how many things in life are held together with just one screw.
The neutral one is the one that we tried out in Target that we loved. The other one was just one that I came across today while looking at the first ones reviews:) It is very very beautiful but you are right, we will want to have another baby someday and I believe he would look pretty silly sitting in a pink swing with butterflies! lol
My second son fell off my bed one morning. Yes, my claim to shame. I took him to the ER-they told me to relax, he was fine, it wasn't a very far fall, and that they see that every single day. It happens. :)
yeah, we all make mistakes. And I will make my own. I think I would just hate to choose a swing that has a major problem with it that I dont know about..
What is the site where you can check on recalls? I tried googling but there are tons of sites and if there is an official one, I would love that one.
Thanks MG:)
Nicole, I looked up the features of both swings and I think in the end not only is the neutral one great for both sexes but it also reclines (the other one doesnt mention that in the ad) and I like that feature because I dont want her head bobbing from side to side, you know? Also the toys hang down (which we like) and I like the nature sounds as well:)
I think trying it out in the store really made it win our hearts in the end because it was just a really nice swing.
oooooo i didnt know that..thank you for letting me know! buying all of the toys and such needed for children, its nice to have the capability to receive emails every time something is recalled.
We really really liked the Eddie Bauer PackNPlay after using it in Target while we were home but I am reading the site that MG posted and it has been recalled. They have since improved it but that still worries me..I am thinking we may just go with a regular Graco P&P.