And a child died when he was hit by a car-there is no separation of the "traffic" area and the "play" area-you have to walk through the traffic to get to the water.
And my opinion-yes, ban driving on the beach. I would not take my kids to a beach where there are cars driving around-that's like setting up a swing set in a parking lot.
I don't care how well you watch them-sh!t happens. Kids run. Drivers could be distracted.
Cars have no place at the beach-except in a designated parking area.
I don't see why anyone would want to drive on the beach anyways. It seems pretty stupid.
However: Of the some 40 miles of beaches in the county, only about 17 miles are still open for cars. Vehicles pay a $5 toll for access, and there is a 10 mph speed limit.
You could just keep your kids out of the 17 miles of beach that allow driving. Why do they need to outlaw something just because people are not smart enough to engage in it properly?
It is kind of like putting a swing set in a parking lot. If a child gets hurt there though, I would still blame the parents. What kind of an idiot would let their kids play on a swing set where a car could hit them? Same thing. I could see if the whole beach had vehicles all over it. This is just one section though. Seems like they already knew it was a safety concern and compramised by pleasing both sides. No drivng on most of the beach, and driving on a small part. If those parents are too stupid to keep their kids out of that dangerous situation, then thats their fault.
Not that 17 miles of beach. Thats the point. There is only 17 miles that is a designated drive zone. So they can avoid them. For the people who like to drive on it...the beach is a place to drive lol. I think it is stupid too, but apparently some people think the beach is meant for driving. Who's to say the people who think its for playing are right?
And 17 miles of beach is a LOT. Think of how small the beaches are around here.
I haven't been to Florida in years, but I can't imagine the beaches stretch for miles-so to have nearly half of your beaches set up to allow cars really limits people on where they can go to avoid the cars.
Not that 17 miles of beach. Thats the point. There is only 17 miles that is a designated drive zone.
See my above comment, lol.
17 miles of beach is vastly different than 17 miles of road.
That would be like living at Kadena and having to drive to Okuma(or further) to avoid cars. I can't imagine there are 17 miles of public beach between Kadena and Okuma.
[i]And 17 miles of beach is a LOT. Think of how small the beaches are around here.
I haven't been to Florida in years, but I can't imagine the beaches stretch for miles-so to have nearly half of your beaches set up to allow cars really limits people on where they can go to avoid the cars. [/i]
It said there were 40 miles of beach in that county. So it is only almost half in that county that are meant for driving. They can always go a county over. I understand what you are saying, but you are only looking at it from the "beaches are for playing" side. I am sure the "beaches are for driving" side thinks that they only have 17 miles in one county to drive on, that really limits where they can go to avoid the people. I'm not saying I agree with them but I do believe in fairness. So people have to go to a different county in order to be away from cars and not be crowded. Thats their choice. They can always stay in their county and be crowded. Or stay on the driving side and put themselves and their children in danger. They have a choice. I dont think its fair to take away the driving sides choice. They should have a place to practice their ridiculous driving on the beach too.
[i]why can't they just make an area for safety sake, and the people drive where ever outside the ropes? [/i]
They tried to. Hence the 17 miles that are designated for driving. They cannot drive anywhere else. They were just being nice and letting people use their discretion about safely moving about the beach. I guess they could just ban people from bringing people of a certain age there to walk around. If youre under 18 you cant go to the driving beach or something lol
[i]some woman sun bathing was run over there too though, not up walking around in front of cars. [/i]
Well what and idiot she was for sunbathing around cars lol Just bc you are allowed to be there doesn't mean you should. I am pretty sure there isn't a law against sunbathing all day long for 3 days straight, but if someone did they would probably die. We shouldn't have to ban things bc people don't know how to keep themselves safe. The idiots ruin it for everyone. If you know there are cars driving around the beach, why would you lay down? lmao Same for the drivers though. If you know people are around, why would you continue to drive around? Especially when you know there is a high probability that you could run someone over. I wouldn't put myself in that situation on either side. I wouldn't want to play around cars, and I wouldn't want to drive that close to people. I feel sorry for the people that need rules in order to make proper decisions about their safety.
I think though that the issue is that it's mixed use.
If it's okay for kids to play and people to sunbathe at that beach, then shouldn't they be allowed to do that?
Or, close those beaches off to people entirely.
It sounds as if there isn't really a way for people to be safe on the beach with cars-unless it's set up like a road.
I agree that it's sad that there needs to be rules in order to stay safe-but then again, why else do we have traffic lights, crosswalk, etc.
Have you ever been to a city that has no traffic lights/crosswalks,etc? It's a NIGHTMARE trying to determine when it's safe to cross the street-especially at an intersection.
Rules are made for a reason.
If there was a clear "road" made on the beach, and crosswalks and such, sure. Mixed use. but if there is not, I think the less-deadly part of the equation has the right of way.
"There's no barrier or median separating the driving lanes. Beachgoers have to cross the traffic lanes to get to the water, and when the tide rises, there is less room for children to play."
Also, one of the commentators on the site had a good argue against tradition and how tradition can become outdated.
"Times change. Just because something is considered a time honored tradition doesn't make it safe or sensible."
Just a question. Would you be okay with cars being allowed to drive through any of the parks on base?
Say, Kinney park? Would you honestly say it's fine to have the cars drive right up to the play structures and that people should just find another park?
I'm honestly interested in your opinion about this.
I agree with you Nicole. I just think that they have a dilema though bc who is to say which activity is the "right" thing. I think it is ok for people to play and sunbathe and I think they should have the right to do it. But other people think it is ok to drive on the beach. Something about their culture (which I think is a joke btw). So shouldnt they have the right to do that too? Who is to say who's "right" is actually right? I understand why rules are made, but I feel like they already addressed it. I think that is why they made the rule that only a certain portion of the beach was meant for driving. Seeing as how people have to drive the vehicle to get there, I dont see how they can ban people from being on the driving beach. So that's why I suggested maybe having an age limit. Like adults only. I am guessing they dont want to make rules for mixed use bc then that could be seen as promoting it. I dont see how anyone in their right mind would want to promote playing around on a beach with cars driving around. I think the people who make the rules are probably trying to stay away from having to take an actual stance on it and pick a "side." I bet they do not want to alienate one group of beachgoers. They probably hoped they could get by with just designating one area ok for driving and hope that people would make the right choice. I guess if enough people die they will have to take action and certain people will have to pick a "side." I am guessing they will pick whatever side has the most voters. lmao
I had no clue there were beaches you can drive on. I've never been to one.
I think that if they just outlawed it-sure, people would grumble, but eventually, that would become tradition.
And screw tradition when it puts lives in danger. It used to be traditional to put candles on Christmas trees. I can't think of anyone in their right mind that would do that now.
[i]Just a question. Would you be okay with cars being allowed to drive through any of the parks on base?
Say, Kinney park? Would you honestly say it's fine to have the cars drive right up to the play structures and that people should just find another park?
I'm honestly interested in your opinion about this. [/i]
No I don't think they should allow cars to drive right up and I dont think that people should have to find a new park. The difference though is the park, with playground equipment, is a designated place for play. So the players have the right of way.(right of way is the best thing I could come up with lol) If someone wanted to put a playground in the middle of a parking lot though...then yes, I would say they need to find a new place for their playground equipment bc it was a designated space for vehicles. In this situation you have a beach...which even though most people play on it...some people drive on it. They saw it was dangerous and then designated a certain portion to be for driving. Since that spot has been designated for driving...then yes...I think the people who want to play freely without worrying about being hit by a car should find a new place to play. I don't think it is ok to take the drivers portion away from them just bc their activity is not really practical or popular. Its pretty stupid to drive on a beach, but apparently they want to. And enough people wanted to that the county decided they needed to designate a spot for it. Why should we take away their designated spot bc people dont know how to make proper decisons about being safe there?
They saw it was dangerous and then designated a certain portion to be for driving. Since that spot has been designated for driving...then yes...I think the people who want to play freely without worrying about being hit by a car should find a new place to play.
Did you see the picture with the article? It's not like there is a place designated for cars. It's more like there are cars wherever on the beach and you have to be careful to not get hit. THAT's my issue. The road is a designated place for cars, as is a parking lot. People walk through parking lots, sure, but they're not competing with the cars for a spot to put their towel.
I think that if they are going to allow it, cars need to be on the furthest part of the beach from the shore, and people can get their lazy butts out of the car and walk down to the shore.
[i]Did you see the picture with the article? It's not like there is a place designated for cars. [/i]
But there is lol Its the 17 miles of beach. That is designated for driving. Avoid that 17 miles. There is another 23 miles, in that county, that you can be on without worrying about cars. There is probably quite a few more miles in a different county too.
It said the father went a few yards to wash his hands in the water and his son ran behind him and that is when he got hit. It doesn't sound like there was even enough space to even have an area for leisure activity from where they drove/park.
I myself have never seen or heard of people other than beach patrol parking/driving on the beach.
I've been to daytime numerous times. There are plenty of other areas to go where there are no cars. Apparently, the child was more than just a few yards away from the dad.
I think that if they are going to allow it, cars need to be on the furthest part of the beach from the shore, and people can get their lazy butts out of the car and walk down to the shore.
See I dont think it is bc they want to be close to the shore though. I dont think its bc they dont want to walk far to get to the water. I think it has something to do with actually driving on the beach, like next to the surf. Some kind of tradition or something. So making them park and walk to the shore isnt really going to meet the need that they are asking for. (from my understanding of what they want at least)
I can see why they dont want to waste money or time on puttiing roads and crosswalks and all that crap. Then they would have to police it. Lots of money would probably go into maintaining the roads, crosswalks, staffing police to uphold the law. All that kind of crap. I think they took the cheap way and said, ok fine...here is your 17 miles. Everyone watch out there are cars here. And then washed their hands of it. The government cant babysit everything. If people want to enter into the driving zone of the beach then they do so at their own risk.
If people want to enter into the driving zone of the beach then they do so at their own risk.
But the point is that there is no driving zone set apart from the rest of it. There is no part of the beach that says "cars only". So, you have drives trying to dodge families trying to walk down to the shore.
There is no specific area set aside for cars only. Maybe they should close that beach to people then.
[i]I myself have never seen or heard of people other than beach patrol parking/driving on the beach. [/i]
That's bc it seems like most people understand why it is not safe. It seems like these people have some kind of deep love of driving on the beach bc of the Daytona 500 or something that they just HAVE to have their drive space.