Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Can my husbands Gunny "inspect" My house?

who's talking here?

LeavinOkiIn09 1
Kitty 7
MOMZ 5
notmuchlonger 1
chica 1
stephine 1
boone 3
lilmama 1
nikita08 1
MRSBUHBUHBANKS 6
my own woman 1
Nicole 7
Paul 1
AirborneWife 2
Blowmedown 1
NikkiB 2
Loved living in Oki 4
mwr885 16
Nicole 3
Romanichel 1
SemperFiChic 4
Str8FrCali 1
TheGoodLife 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

MRSBUHBUHBANKS --- 17 years ago -

So today when my husband came to get his things a Sgt was with him and I guess that Sgt told the Company Gunny that my house smelled so now the Gunny is dropping my husband off on Monday and wants to inspect our house, is he allowed to do that? 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

The only people allowed to search your house is the base police with a warrant signed by the commanding officer. You could refuse entry, however that may make things rough for your husband at work. 

my own woman --- 17 years ago -

They can do whatever they want. It is not your house it is the militarys and if they feel like you are not taking care of their property they can kick you out. Or tell you to make sure you dont mess it up. Thats what I was told. 

NikkiB --- 17 years ago -

They can do whatever they want. It is not your house it is the militarys and if they feel like you are not taking care of their property they can kick you out. Or tell you to make sure you dont mess it upĀ  Yeah but I would think it's not up to someone in her husband's command to decide that. If they have an issue, they should bring it up with housing and housing will send someone out to inspect it...or like mwr said, send the base police. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

They can do whatever they want. It is not your house it is the militarys and if they feel like you are not taking care of their property they can kick you out. Or tell you to make sure you dont mess it up Housing perhaps but not his Gunny. Like I said, the only people that are allowed to enter your house are base police with a warrant or probable cause for illegal activity. I know this as I have attended school for this very thing. 

MRSBUHBUHBANKS --- 17 years ago -

They can do whatever they want. It is not your house it is the militarys and if they feel like you are not taking care of their property they can kick you out. Or tell you to make sure you dont mess it up Yea but thats HOUSING not any higher up of his that just wants to come into my house right? 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

If you are an E4 I cannot just decide to inspect your house becuase I am an E5 or even an O9. There are rules for this sort of thing. 

nikita08 --- 17 years ago -

you can refuse it yes, and if you have other problems, contact legal or housing or something. 

Str8FrCali --- 17 years ago -

Something just happened recently at my husbands unit, where it had to do with a family on base housing. And they sent out a SSGT & above to look at all the families houses to see how theyre treating base housing. I know a SSGT came here, but I wasnt worried about it. So I think under certain circumstances they can. 

stephine --- 17 years ago -

not sure, but i guess you have the weekend to clean :/ i think they are just trying to make things hard for you from your previous post :/ don't back down but i also think that yeah, its the military's house so i think that they can BUT with a warrant of what they might be looking for ya know. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

I get fired up about this issue. Sorry if I step on any toes. I am no great legal mind but I would like to point at the 4th Amendment: The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. If you want the right answer, call the local PMO and ask. In the end all of us here on OU are just "sea lawyers" 

LeavinOkiIn09 --- 17 years ago -

Yeah but I would think it's not up to someone in her husband's command to decide that. If they have an issue, they should bring it up with housing and housing will send someone out to inspect it...or like mwr said, send the base police. my hussband SSGT has inspected ours... they do it like once a year for everyone in his battery. I don't care cuz I know its not nasty :) 

NikkiB --- 17 years ago -

mwr885 - did you ever tell your wife that I said hello?! 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

I have always been told that as long as we are living under the military, we are suspect to inspections of any kind including by my husband's superiors. That is not to say that I do not disagree with it. Frankly I think that if anyone were to want to inspect my house it would have to be the police with a valid warrant BUT there are a lot of things about the military that slide past the rules as they are stated and should be. 

Loved living in Oki --- 17 years ago -

It's similar to living in the barracks. Single guys just have to field day and get inspected regularly. You can be inspected at any time in housing (from what I understand) it's just rare that you are. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

I'm thinking that if they have a "valid" reason to look, then yes, they can. As many pointed out, it is military property. Unfortunately, I think many of your 4th Amendment rights stop at the gates. I am guessing that even if your house is fine, they are trying to make your life hell. The best thing to do-first, ask a good friend who will be honest if your house smells. And I suggest cleaning up if they say it does smell. I'm sorry that this is happening. I would document everything-just so you have proof that you are being harassed, if it comes to that. Also, the suggestion of going to legal is a really, really good one. I would call them first thing Monday morning. You need to be advised of ALL of your rights. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

It's similar to living in the barracks. Single guys just have to field day and get inspected regularly. You can be inspected at any time in housing (from what I understand) it's just rare that you are. Barrack inspections are authorized by the commanding officer. Check up it is in writing. Housing inspections are not authorized "on a whim". Unfortunately, I think many of your 4th Amendment rights stop at the gates. Unless you recently stopped being American, your rights are still valid. This is why when I arrest someone (even military) if I don't follow the rules EXACTLY I will end up being the one in jail. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

I would call them first thing Monday morning. You need to be advised of ALL of your rights Best advice in this thread. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

Unless you recently stopped being American, your rights are still valid. This is why when I arrest someone (even military) if I don't follow the rules EXACTLY I will end up being the one in jail. Yes, that is true, but the military reserves the right to search you or your property when you are on base/post. Think of all the times that your car gets searched when coming in the gate-bomb stuff and all. Maybe they don't do that here? I just know that while you can refuse that particular search, then they won't let you on base. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

Another search specifically authorized by the commanding officer (in writing) with procedures that must be followed. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

Another search specifically authorized by the commanding officer (in writing) with procedures that must be followed. really? I haven't had it here, but I've had my car stopped more than once in the past oh, almost 14 years I've been driving and randomly searched by SF and dogs. I was never given anything in writing. It was going in the gate-checking randomly for illegal drugs, weapons, etc. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

and I take that back about here. We had to unroll our windows one night going off-base so they could check to make sure a missing child wasn't in our car. We weren't asked nor presented with paperwork asking our permission to look in the car. We were just told they needed to check. they checked everyone's car. 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

A lot of the rights that the military fight for so that we can be "American" are not quite the way they were intended for military members. I figure that out more and more every day. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

You were not given anything in writing. It is written somewhere, that by accepting the right to enter the base you are accepting the their right to search your car. The issue here is different. An E7 cannot randomly decide to "inspect" someone's home without the Commanding Officer's consent. Does this mean I am allowed to inspect all of my E4 and below's homes to ensure they are cleaning and folding their socks to standards? 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

It is written in the base policy letters for your particular base. BTW 

Loved living in Oki --- 17 years ago -

Maybe it's not to "inspect" the house as we interpret the word. Maybe he wants to see for himself what this Sgt is saying to prevent someone else from calling housing on his Marine about the "smell". 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

Maybe it's not to "inspect" the house as we interpret the word. Maybe he wants to see for himself what this Sgt is saying to prevent someone else from calling housing on his Marine about the "smell". That is feasible. This is just one of those issues that gets me wound up! Sorry for veering so high and right! 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

You were not given anything in writing. It is written somewhere, that by accepting the right to enter the base you are accepting the their right to search your car. But by living on base, in a military house, aren't you then authorizing them to search the house, simply b/c it's gov't property? I'm not trying to argue, this is just what I have always believed when it came to housing. I mean, hell, they have the right to write you up if you have weeds in your yard, why not inspect the inside too? (and for the record, I think it's BS and is only b/c she called PMO on him) 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

But seeing as how paperwork needs to be done and not presented how would know if there was paperwork or an order to that e7 to inspect the house by a higher up? Would the e4 in question be reprimanded for asking for paperwork. Not SHOULD he but WOULD he. 

MRSBUHBUHBANKS --- 17 years ago -

My house isnt dirty thats the thing, The reason they want to come is because the guy said my house smelled! I have two dogs who are pretty inside dogs. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground