Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Unfair Child Support Laws

who's talking here?

Steph 1
Loved living in Oki 18
Nicole 3
ChiTownGrl 3
Casey 12
Daniel 1
Bad Speller 26
Señor H 1
Why? 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

http://mobile.associatedcontent.com/article/355734/presumed_fathers_act_should_a_man_pay_pg3.html?cat=25 Even if a child is not biologically you can be forced to pay child support. An example given was "a wife cheats on her husband, gets pregnant, gives birth then they get divorced later down the road, he proves from a DNA test that the kid is not his, but he is forced to pay child support because she had the kid while they were married" I think this is pure BS. Thoughts..... 

Steph --- 16 years ago -

It's unfair yes, but the state has a duty to the child to not leave it as basically a bastard. If the husband signed the birth certificate, he's legally obligated to support the child even if it's not his. It works the same way for a man who signs the paperwork for a child he knows isn't his (as in, if he marries a woman who was already pregnant when they met or what have you). If they can find the actual father, the support obligation would fall to him instead. We learned all this when researching the stripping of paternal rights a few years back. The state won't strip a father's rights without another male to step up and assume that legal obligation (there are other criteria that have to be met as well). 

Señor H --- 16 years ago -

But bastard kids are the best. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

M, you're slipping. No comment about the lack of a clicky link? 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

If we were still counting points, I think a deduction would be in order. 

Casey --- 16 years ago -

it'd be BS if he didn't ever sign the birth certificate or adopt the child that wasn't his, but if he does that- he chose to support that child, just like if he'd had a biological child in the first place. if he doesn't want to support the kid, he shouldn't have signed anything, or should find the real daddy and give the rights over. i'm pretty sure my cousin's ex doesn't pay him child support. she's supposed to, but doesn't, and i doubt they'd ever press her for it. she's a nut. it'd cause more problems than it's worth, and he's worked hard to build his business so he can afford to support his 3 kids without her help. 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

i'm pretty sure my cousin's ex doesn't pay him child support. she's supposed to, but doesn't, and i doubt they'd ever press her for it. she's a nut. it'd cause more problems than it's worth, I know of a couple people like that. It makes me wonder if the person responsible for the child support makes it difficult on purpose so that it's not even worth the fight. It's so sad. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

The state has a duty to uphold justice. It shouldn't matter IMHO what he signed. If DNA says it's not his he shouldn't be forced to pay. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

So the child suffers because some guy wants to be an a-hole. That sounds fair.  It sounds more fair then forcing somebody to support a kd that's not his. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

uphold justice. It's justice for a child to suffer? 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

He supported the kid that far because a) he didn't know it wasn't his or b) for tge relationship. It's sad for tge kid but that's the mothers fault. I can't see how or why it's okay to force somebody to support a kid that's not theirs. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

People are stupid and life's not fair. If you start supporting a kid, of your own free will, do the right thing and continue to help that kid. 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

I think it's different if you know the kid isn't yours and sign the birth certificate anyways. If your partner cheated and you have no idea the kid isn't biologically yours, I don't think it's fair for the guy to have to pay even if he did sign the birth certificate. *EDIT*- He shouldn't be forced to pay, even though morally it would be the right thing to do. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

*EDIT*- He shouldn't be forced to pay, even though morally it would be the right thing to do.  Now this I can understand. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

Love living in Oki --- If you start supporting a kid, of your own free will, do the right thing and continue to help that kid.  Why? Maybe he never wanted kids and only took care of it for the woman. Since there's no more relationship and he has proof it's not his and now wants his life back. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

That's what's wrong with the world. People care too much about being right and not enough about having morals. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

Why? Because it's the right thing to do. No one forced you to start taking care of the kid from the beginning. That kid didn't ask to be born, didn't ask to have a crappy mom and didn't ask you to begin supporting him. It's unfair to take that away from him because you aren't getting any from his mom anymore. I would hope, for most normal people, that you would have formed some sort of bond with the kid during your relationship with his mom. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

Love living in Oki --- 48 sec ago - quote - flag comment That's what's wrong with the world. People care too much about being right and not enough about having morals.  Morals? So it's not immoral to force someone to pay for a kd that's not theirs? It's a nice thng to do and I admire someone who does it. I just find it wrong and immoral for the system to force it. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

So it's not immoral to force someone to pay for a kd that's not theirs? Sure, if they randomly picked some dude off the street who had no connection to him. In this instance, no. 

Nicole --- 16 years ago -

That's pretty damn sad that he doesn't love the kid enough (who he thought was his) to support it. So, he thought this baby was his, helped raise the kid until a divorce, and then suddenly doesn't want/love the kid anymore? He should get a forced vasectomy. that would solve his issue. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

So if a woman has an affair, gets pregnant, the guy has no clue and thinks it's his, finds out the truth 5 years later, they get divorced. He should be forced to pay child support? That's insane. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

So, he thought this baby was his, helped raise the kid until a divorce, and then suddenly doesn't want/love the kid anymore? Basically. He'll make a great real dad someday. 

Nicole --- 16 years ago -

That's insane. What's more insane is that he can love a child as his own for 5 years and then, like a damn faucet, turn it off. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

Exactly. He thought the kid was his so he did the right thing. But now since he found out it's not his he wants his freedom. Women get all the choices when it comes to being a mother. They can have an abortion, put the baby up for adoption, raise the baby single, recieve child support or be married and build a family. But men are just stuck with whatever the woman wants. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

What's more insane is that he can love a child as his own for 5 years and then, like a damn faucet, turn it off. Exactly. I hope he never adopts. He'll get tired of taking care of the kid and want to give him back. 

Nicole --- 16 years ago -

But now since he found out it's not his he wants his freedom. I get that it sucks for him, but he's not much of a man if that's how he thinks. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

but he's not much of a man There you go. 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

What about the guy she cheated with? Why is he in the clear. But a guy that doesn't want to support a kid that's not his is a POS? He thought the kid was his and now it's not and doesn't want to continue supporting another man's kid. Or this happens too and makes me mad. The guy loves the kid and takes care of it after all this and all of a sudden the " real dad" wants to be in the picture and tge court sides with the "real dad". 

Bad Speller --- 16 years ago -

After five years how do you just stop loving your child? Anyone who can just turn that off deserves to be shot because there is something seriously wrong.  Because he thought it was his. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

Because he thought it was his. He's the only dad that kid has ever known. To that kid, it's still his dad even if the man didn't contribute that one sperm. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground