Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Child abuse?

who's talking here?

Krystle 2
Balls To The Wall 2
Loved living in Oki 9
Nicole 12
ChiTownGrl 11
Casey 2
The Dramallama 1
Misses Eriksson 1
JessicaB 1
All Abouts 1
yourmomdotcom 12
sToO 1
Blue fuzzy creature 2
SFC :) 1
madmel 3
sam 2
Proud Army Wife 2
Fatalxception 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

Child abuse or discipline?

Thoughts? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I read the article. I didn't watch the video-I didn't want to see it. Just based on the description though I would classify it as abusive. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

Nicole, if you read the article without watching the video, it makes it sound worse than it was, in my opinion. The article makes it sound like she pours tons of hot sauce in his mouth, when it's really only a dab.

I don't think it's anymore abusive than parents making their kids eat soap. At least hot sauce is meant to be consumed. If she gets prosecuted, then parents who make their kids eat soap should be too. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

The screaming wasn't any worse than what my kids have done while getting a time out. 

Soon people are going to start saying time outs are emotional abuse. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I don't understand the purpose of the cold shower. Why? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

So, I watched it. I can see the hot sauce part I guess. I don't agree with it though. The shower though seems awfully cruel.

Obviously, her method of discipline doesn't work, since her child seems to know/expect what's happening. It obviously hasn't made a difference in behavior. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

I agree that it isn't working, but I don't think she should go to jail for it. I don't understand a lot of what other parents do with their kids, but it doesn't make it abuse. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Don't most children know what kind of punishment they will get and misbehave anyway?

This is true. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I agree that it isn't working, but I don't think she should go to jail for it.

I don't think she needs jail. Maybe some help would be appropriate. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Don't most children know what kind of punishment they will get and misbehave anyway? 

It seems even the most well behaved children misbehave at some point even if they know they'll get in trouble. 

yourmomdotcom --- 15 years ago -

Abuse? NO... effective? Again NO!!

Just because something is uncomfortable to a child doesn't make it abuse. I just don't see either "technique" being particularly effective.

Now if it's prolonged exposure to something beyond 8000 on the Scoville or if the child is put in a cold shower for longer than a few minutes and not allowed to dry off- that would in fact be abuse because you are causing long term damage and or death. But a little "Texas Pete" and some cold water isn't too bad IMO.

Hey- at least she didn't shoot them on the way to a soccer game or while using the computer!! 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I don't know....there's just something about it that bothers me. I do understand the frustration though. My older one is like that. And yeah, it seems sometimes like nothing really works. :( 

yourmomdotcom --- 15 years ago -

My kids do time out several times a week, does that mean it isn't working? Maybe we should try hot sauce.

I'm a fan of soup cans and the Roman chair myself. Although I'm not above hotsauce for cussing or backtalk. 

yourmomdotcom --- 15 years ago -

The other factor to consider, IMO, is age. Not everything is appropriate for all ages. Hotsauce wouldn't work for my kids I don't think- all my kids are teens though. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Hotsauce wouldn't work for my kids I don't think- all my kids are teens though. 

Put it in their eye. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Just out of curiosity...did it say why she sent the tape to Dr. Phil?? 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

I'm not sure, but from what I saw on the Today Show today, it was because she wanted help with learning how to handle the kids. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I feel bad if it's going to backfire on her. Unless she's done something way worse, I don't think this qualifies as something they should think about prosecuting her for. Nothing like punishing someone who is asking for help. :( 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

I couldn't agree more. 

Proud Army Wife --- 15 years ago -

I don't know that it's so much the hot sauce- when I used to suck my thumb- my mom would put hot sauce on my thumb so I wouldn't do it.

BUT, the cold shower- is RIDICULOUS- and I consider that abuse.

I don't know if Jail is the answer- I think she needs to go to some parenting classes to learn how to discipline effectively. 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

Yeah I think the cold shower was a bit harsh...I felt bad for him...not so much the hot sauce but the shower part...two punshments for one bad choice... 

madmel --- 15 years ago -

My question is what in the world this lady was thinking having her 10 year old record the punisment and then sending it into Dr. Phil! Does she not get enough attention at home from her husband? Stupid people I swear.

I do give my children hot sause once in a great while when they do lie or to me or back talk several times. I have also used soap in the past. As far as a cold shower goes I think that's a little excesive. Personally I'm a big fan of the invisable chair and pushups but that's just me. My kids get punished while getting a workout in at the same time. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

My question is what in the world this lady was thinking having her 10 year old record the punisment and then sending it into Dr. Phil! Does she not get enough attention at home from her husband? Stupid people I swear.


If you read the rest of the posts, I already answered this question. She was looking for help on how to better handle her children. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

For those that agree with the hot sauce and not the cold shower, can someone explain the difference to me? I am being serious. The way I see it, both are physical punishment and you either agree with physical punishment or you don't. The hot sauce will burn his mouth and the shower makes his body cold. I just really don't see much of a difference. It's not like she's leaving him in the shower for hours. And honestly, who really even knows how cold the shower is. What I consider a cold shower, my husband still considers warm. 

madmel --- 15 years ago -

If you read the rest of the posts, I already answered this question. She was looking for help on how to better handle her children.

Then she should have went to her pediatrician or a chil psycologist now Dr. Phil. There were other avenues. I think she wanted her 15 minutes of fame. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

I think she wanted her 15 minutes of fame. 

Yes because everyone enjoys being embarrassed on national television. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

For those that agree with the hot sauce and not the cold shower, can someone explain the difference to me? I am being serious.

I don't agree with either-but I'm honestly not sure what makes the shower seem worse to me. Maybe because it seems more dangerous? Maybe because taking a shower (or bath) is such a basic thing that it seems wrong to link it to punishment? I honestly don't know why that struck me as worse, just that it did. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

Nicole I understand what you're saying but the same could be said for the hot sauce. Eating is also a basic function and putting something in his mouth as a punishment could have the same consequences. 

madmel --- 15 years ago -

Hey Nicole I finally broke down this week and bought my new running shoes this last weekend. They're killing my feet because they need to be broke in but my knees no longer hurt when I run. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground