Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Do you agree with .......

who's talking here?

Paul 8
Krystle 1
Balls To The Wall 4
Loved living in Oki 26
Nicole 1
The Gunny 6
ChiTownGrl 27
Casey 2
Misses Eriksson 4
♥Mrs. Boss ♥ 2
Angel 4
Oh.Mee.Gawd! 2
Blue fuzzy creature 13
Illbehave 18
Victoria 19
Team OYS 14
Proud Army Wife 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Do you agree with .......

Do you agree that when a military member and their spouse are married for over 10 years and he retires from the military and they happen to get divorced that she/he is entitled to half of their retirement? **The husband and I were talking about this the other day. Thought it would make for interesting conversation. :-)**

Yes: Vote
 
 54.2% (13)
No: Vote
 
 45.8% (11)
♥Mrs. Boss ♥ --- 16 years ago -

Do you agree that when a military member and their spouse are married for over 10 years and he retires from the military and they happen to get divorced that she/he is entitled to half of their retirement?

**The husband and I were talking about this the other day. Thought it would make for interesting conversation. :-)** 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

I don't know about half. Perhaps a different percentage though. Military or not doesn't matter. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

 

Casey --- 16 years ago -

depends on the situation. 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

I think it should depend on the income of the other spouse after the divorce and whether or not the spouse that wasn't active duty remarries, the same way alimony does. If the military member always earned a living and the spouse stayed home and raised kids without an education, it's only fair to be sure he/she is taken care of while they get established on their own. 

Casey --- 16 years ago -

i thought i read somewhere that if they remarry it stops payment, just like alimony does. 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

No way. No special treatment for military spouses. Keep it just as it is now. 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

Oh, ok. I don't know anything about it. This is the first I had heard of it. 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

I think it's fair, when the vast majority of military spouses are stay at home moms, or only able to work part time, they aren't able to rack up a 401k or even have a real resume when they need it.
We both have Roth IRA's, we're not going to rely solely on retirement. 

Loved living in Oki --- 16 years ago -

Half? I should get all of it. 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

I think it also depends on who gets the children in the divorce, the spouse would not deserve a single penny if they don't have custody of the children... 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

Hell no.

+1 

Nicole --- 16 years ago -

Hell no.

+1


He forgot to mention he's already past the point of no return. :D 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

Hell no.

+1

He forgot to mention he's already past the point of no return. :D


I am a spouse past "the point of no return" and don't think we deserve half. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

No way. No special treatment for military spouses. Keep it just as it is now.


It isn't special treatment for military spouses. There are plenty of other professions that deal with this too. The military really has nothing to do with it. If your husband was an accountant and you wanted to petition for a part of his retirement during divorce you could.

If the military member always earned a living and the spouse stayed home and raised kids without an education, it's only fair to be sure he/she is taken care of while they get established on their own.

That's mostly alimony that deals with that though. Basically for the retirement thing you are paying into your future during those years. You both have this fund for your future. (If the spouse isn't contributing to their own fund) So it only makes sense that if you get kicked to the curb that you would demand to have those ten years or whatever it is that you also were counting on that retirement back. That is why I don't think it should be half. It should be a percentage. Only larger for the greater amount of time spent counting on that future with the spouse. This would be in addition to any alimonies you are entitled to, if any.
Amount of time matters, but circumstance matters too. If you are blindsided by a divorce then it only seems fair to petition for these things. Since you were counting on them and the spouse led you to believe your future together was secure. Now if other things were going on and you knew it was over long ago (long seperation), you were a cheater, or cause of the dissolution, etc. then you should not be entitled to any of it. 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

If they get divorced after retirement it should be treated as any income is treated be it everything split in half or however it works.

But there really shouldn't be any alimony in the first place.

If they get divorced before retirement then HELL fvcking NO! 

Krystle --- 16 years ago -

I always thought it was 15 years... Heck yes! 5 years closer! ;)


On a serious note, I think that they should be married a little longer than 10 years in order to receive half a persons retirement. 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

Victoria- the difference with military retirement is that it begins so early (which could be at 38 years old) so when the couple divorces, the active duty member may already be retired and receiving that money. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

Victoria- the difference with military retirement is that it begins so early (which could be at 38 years old) so when the couple divorces, the active duty member may already be retired and receiving that money.


I thought they were eluding that it was only possible for military spouses to get some of their spouses retirement. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

But there really shouldn't be any alimony in the first place.


Why do you think there shouldn't be any alimony? 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

Oh ok. I'm not sure what they were talking about because that isn't true. I just don't think military retirement is comparable to retirement pay in the private sector because of the age that you can collect it. 

Illbehave --- 16 years ago -

Why do you think there shouldn't be any alimony


Because the spouses should keep what's there's. Now a house or thngs they both own should be split or whatever.

CHILD support is a must.

But there should be no having to pay an ex spouse money just because. They can get a fuxking job. No free ride. 

The Gunny --- 16 years ago -

Ok, the Gunny has to weigh in on this one! The 10 year rule is a DFAS rule. It was the Former Spouses Protection Act (which I think is B.S.) that allows military retired pay to be treated as "community property" in a divorce. So you could only be married for say, 3 years, and still get some of the retirement pay. It is up to the judge and the state laws where the divorce is done. If they were married less than 10 years, then DFAS won't pay the ex-spouse directly. If more than 10 years, then they get a direct deposit from DFAS just like they were the retiree themselves. Example: I know a guy that got divorced after six yrs of marriage. He was already approaching 20 years of service. The judge awarded a small amount of the retirement pay (like 13.5% or something) to the ex-wife. Since they were married less than 10 years (and DFAS wouldn't pay directly), he had to cut her a check for the money himself. I think the law is bull. A spouse married a military person knowing that most likely their own career would suffer (or they would never even get one). I have never seen a wife at PT. I have never seen a wife freezing in a cold tent. I have never seen a wife deployed on a ship. I have never seen a wife in Iraq/Afghanistan. I don't think it is a fair law at all. It was a female congresswoman that pushed the law though I believe.

Don't beleive the Gunny though, look it up for yourself....or go see a lawyer (a real one, not one on base). 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

That's weird. I've never seen my husband be pregnant, give birth or breastfeed but my daughter is just as much his as she is mine. 

Balls To The Wall --- 16 years ago -

I guess I will go back and forth on this because it really depends on the situation.

If Sally wants to leave Joe after 10 years because she is tired of him, heck no.

If Joe cheats on Sally. Sally has put her all in the relationship, yes. 

The Gunny --- 16 years ago -

ChiTown - I believe you are confusing child support with retirement pay. I'm a FIRM believer in child support! 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

Gunny - that's why I said before it depends on the situation. What if the kids are still young and living at home when they divorce and he's collecting retirement? Shouldn't part of his retirement pay go to take care of them?

Just because the wife didn't spend time in a cold tent, doesn't mean she was at home sitting on her a$s. She may have been raising 2 kids alone. I just don't like the way you made it sound that since she wasn't active duty that she didn't sacrifice for her husband's military career. Military life is hard on both people in that marriage in different ways. I agree that when you enter a marriage with a military member, you need to be aware of the sacrifices you will make, but the same goes for the AD member. If he doesn't want to chance half of his retirement pay disappearing if things don't work out, he just shouldn't get married. 

The Gunny --- 16 years ago -

ChiTown - I agree, military life is hard on a spouse. I definitely agree that after a split, if the woman has custody of the child(ren), then there should be child support. To say that the woman is owed the retirement pay to cover that child support is not right IMO. Now, if that is the only source of income the guy has, then of course, he would have to pay his child support out of that (that is his business though, not the ex). As long as he pays, where should an ex get off by saying where the money comes from. Again, IMO, the law is BS! 

Blue fuzzy creature --- 16 years ago -

You want a free ride? Great, enjoy it while it lasts. But to say they deserve the retirement pay that is EARNED by serving your country for 20 years, GTFO.


Truer words have never been spoken (or typed) 

ChiTownGrl --- 16 years ago -

You want a free ride? Great, enjoy it while it lasts. But to say they deserve the retirement pay that is EARNED by serving your country for 20 years, GTFO.

I hardly think a military wife has a free ride, but that's my opinion. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground